27/07/2024
Random thoughts on the Opening Ceremony as seen on BBC One (to which I might add through the day):
• good or bad, this is still a supreme television event - global, aspirationally epic, live, and viewed in the home over an extended period via a national broadcaster;; such collective experiences (the Euro 2024 final was another) deserve to be cherished;
• lots of naff stuff, inevitably, and the rain was certainly a challenge (including to the radio links of certain cameras), but there were great bits too - I loved the galloping horse speeding along the Seine, I would have followed mezzo-soprano Axelle Saint-Cirel onto the barricades singing La Marseillaise along with her; the rising statues of famous French feminists were great; Juliette Armanet's 'Imagine' was glorious, although the flaming piano was a puzzle (any ideas?); the laser light show on the Eiffel Tower was 21st century modernity incarnate; goose-bumps for the glorious, grandiloquent balloon torch and that shot, pictured, uniting it with Eiffel's creation; and of course the magnificent Celine Dion;
• live television coverage of such an event, without a full rehearsal, is really, really hard, and the French team did pretty well, but...
• I was struck how tough it was to make the numerous transitions from live to pre-record and back convincing - screen grammar, image quality, sometimes the timings, and more created unproductive jumps;
• and I was truly disappointed by the BBC commentary team, who nattered on from the cheat sheets over the boat shots, and had next-to-nothing to say about the rest - was it because they had no advance notice whatsoever, no running order, no cast list, no notes whatsoever about the dense and delightful network of French cultural references? Even so, failing for example to recognise the figure from Phantom of the Opera, and countless similar lapses felt pretty unforgivable, and offering something entirely unconvincing about the French New Wave when the plot was clearly 'Jules et Jim', and then failing to follow up with something, anything about the library seducation by literature and philosophy leading to the joyful gender-fluid th*****me;
• no, it wasn't 2012, but it was a bold, progressive, youthful, contemporary take on French history, traditions and the world today - and the BBC could have helped us understand that better;
• although kudos to Andrew Cotter for his impromptu simultaneous translation of the speeches, even if he and Hazel Irvine failed (I think) to notice, along with much else, that the Olympic flag had been raised upside down.