![Commentary: Reduce harm on ni****ne products rather than banning themIn April, the Food and Drug Administration announce...](https://img3.medioq.com/602/412/624068806024129.jpg)
09/06/2022
Commentary: Reduce harm on ni****ne products rather than banning them
In April, the Food and Drug Administration announced its plan to ban menthol-flavored ci******es. Although many may celebrate this decision as a groundbreaking victory for public health, it does not take a scholar to recognize that prohibitions tend to fail. Instead of focusing on uplifting our communities and helping smokers move to less-harmful options, a menthol ban will punish those who struggle to quit, while devastating local businesses in its wake.
As a multi-unit convenience store owner and v**e wholesaler, I have spent my entire career in retail. Over the years, I have watched countless officials wrongly support similar policies, seemingly refusing to learn from the mistakes of their colleagues and predecessors. The same story continues to unfold — forced prohibitions take away regulated products from small businesses, fueling unchecked illicit trade in its place.
A recent study by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy stated that nearly 20 percent of all ci******es consumed in Michigan were smuggled in as a function of tax evasion or avoidance, ranking our state 15th nationally. Simply, excessive taxes or a prohibition of certain ci******es or other flavored ni****ne products will increase smuggling and embolden further criminal activity.
Moreover, convenience stores in Michigan typically count on to***co products for nearly 35 percent of their in-store purchases. This number doesn't account for the additional purchases these customers make while visiting our stores. Put simply, these businesses are not prepared to handle the substantial losses expected from a ban on all menthol to***co products.
While the Biden administration has spent much of its time providing extraordinary relief to local businesses across all industries, bans or prohibitions place an unfair burden on convenience stores hit hard by the global pandemic. This is particularly true for stores in traditionally minority neighborhoods, which generally prefer menthol-flavored to***co products.
There is a solution to help consumers quit smoking, and it's known as To***co Harm Reduction. THR is a growing, scientifically substantiated movement to share the potential public health and community benefits of providing to***co smokers access and education to potentially less harmful ni****ne products.
For example, a recent study found that the presence of v***r products not only had little impact on encouraging smoking among young people, but it did encourage more adults who use ci******es to quit. Study after study shows that ni****ne alternatives, including va**ng products, are significantly safer than ci******es, because tar in traditional ci******es causes health problems, not ni****ne.
I know firsthand the benefits of switching because I've applied the THR strategy and transitioned from traditional ci******es to va**ng. Honestly, it's one of the best decisions I've ever made and why I can no longer remain silent over the FDA's attempted shakedown.
Unlike more progressive public health programs in places such as Europe, the FDA does not have a realistic strategy or plan. They may continue to stand behind their decision to enforce prohibitions, but that doesn't change the reality that such a policy will only lead to harmful outcomes. Rather than abandon smokers, we need this administration to support policies that provide opportunities for those that wish to quit.
Prohibition is a failed policy; until the FDA reverses course, history will continue to repeat itself.
Source:crainsdetroit