Scream and Sugar True Crime Coffee Hour

06/25/2025

In this week’s episode of Scream and Sugar, we dive into the chilling double life of Elaine Antoinette Parent—a master manipulator, identity thief, and murderer.
Dubbed “The Chameleon Killer” by authorities, Parent left a trail of forged documents, stolen identities, and at least one gruesome murder in her wake. But how did an upper-middle-class girl from Florida become one of the most elusive suspects in FBI history? And what twisted motives drove her to kill and vanish again and again? Buckle up for a tale of deception, plastic masks, and postcards from the edge—this one is as wild as it is terrifying.

So grab your coffee and your crime scene curiosity—because this week, the truth is wearing someone else’s face. Shout out to Black Rock Desserts for today's review! 

And remember, stay spooky, y’all!

Notes:
Scream and Sugar Merch: scream-and-sugar-podcast.printify.me/
Black Rock Desserts: https://www.blackrockdesserts.com/

Tags

06/24/2025

Merch alert!! We've got the spookiest gear for y'all!! Go check it out on printify: https://scream-and-sugar-podcast.printify.me/

06/18/2025

Welcome back, spooky squad, to another episode of Scream and Sugar, your true crime coffee hour.
In the quiet town of Acme, Washington, the Thanksgiving weekend of 1989 turned into a nightmare. Mandy Stavik, a bright, athletic 18-year-old college freshman, went out for a routine jog with her dog, Kyra, and never came home. Days later, her body was found in the Nooksack River. The case would haunt the community for decades until a shocking DNA breakthrough revealed her killer. Join us as we unpack the chilling details of Mandy’s life, her disappearance, and the long-delayed justice that finally gave her family some peace.
Come sip along with us as we dive into the details surrounding this case, including the amazing women who came together to finally solve it. And remember, to stay spooky, y'all!

https://www.bellinghamherald.com/news/local/crime/article189667204.htmlhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xU7GIDi66xE

Tags

06/11/2025

UPDATE! We now have merch!! Shirts, hoodies, hats, towels, cups, you name it!! Check it out here:
https://scream-and-sugar-podcast.printify.me/

And if there's a product you want but don't see, let us know, and we'll try to make it happen.

Stay spooky, ya'll!!

06/05/2025

Welcome back, Spooky Squad, to Scream and Sugar - your true crime coffee hour. This week, we’re heading to Houston, Texas, to uncover the chilling mystery of the Icebox Murders—a gruesome 1965 double homicide that left investigators reeling.

When police forced entry into the home of elderly couple Fred and Edwina Rogers, what they found inside the refrigerator shocked even seasoned detectives. But the most haunting part? Their reclusive son, Charles, had vanished, leaving behind a house full of clues, cryptic diary entries, and conspiracy theories that converge on the JFK assassination (!). Join us as we untangle the twisted tale of paranoia, espionage, and family secrets. Was Charles Rogers a cold-blooded killer, or was he running from something even darker? Grab your coffee and hang with us as we munch on snacks from Ikeda's in Auburn, CA—this one’s a doozy.

And remember to stay spooky, y'all!!

Case Notes: 
https://www.ikedas.com/

Tags

05/28/2025

This week, we're diving into the chilling and tragic case of Aileen Wuornos—often labeled as America's first female serial killer. But was she truly a cold-blooded predator, or a deeply damaged woman failed by every system around her? Join us as Candace traces Aileen’s turbulent life—from a childhood filled with abuse and abandonment to the Florida highways where seven men met their end. We’ll explore her controversial trial, the media frenzy that followed, and the psychological complexities that still spark debate today.

Was it self-defense, as she claimed, or something much darker? Brew something strong—this one’s heavy. 
And remember to stay spooky, y’all!

Snacks: Ikedas, Auburn, CA https://www.ikedas.com/

Tags

                                 

05/21/2025

Welcome back ya'll! Today, we are diving deep into one of the creepiest cases we've covered. This is one of Brazil’s most disturbing and unexplained cases — the Guarapiranga Reservoir Mutilation. In 1988, the body of an unidentified man was discovered near São Paulo's Guarapiranga Reservoir. What shocked investigators wasn't just the death — it was the horrifying, surgical precision of the mutilations. No blood. No signs of struggle. No clear cause of death. Was it a sadistic human crime, an elaborate cover-up, or something far more unexplainable? Join us as we dissect the forensics, explore the theories — from criminal to paranormal — and piece together the unsettling puzzle that has baffled experts for decades. 

Case Notes: 
https://realhorrordiaries.blogspot.com/2023/01/obscure-occurrences-mystery-behind-body.htmlHow bodies found in water can be difficult to understand: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1756231721001249Stages of decomposition:https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10493-009-9284-9Creeptime link: https://www.reddit.com/r/creeptimethepodcast/comments/1j66rjt/ep_134_the_mutilated_body_discovered_near_brazils/ ://realhorrordiaries.blogspot.com/2023/01/obscure-occurrences-mystery-behind-body.html

Tags

                                     

04/24/2025

Hey Spooky Squad! Welcome back to another episode of Scream and Sugar, your true crime coffee hour. Today, we are talking about a serial killer, or lack thereof, in Austin, Texas, who's allegedly stalking Rainy St. 
Since 2022, a chilling pattern has haunted Austin, Texas—bodies of young men have been found in Lady Bird Lake, near the bustling bars and music venues of Rainy Street. Official reports have often ruled these deaths as accidental or self-inflicted, but locals aren’t convinced.
Are these tragic drownings a coincidence? Or the work of a serial predator hiding in plain sight? In this episode of Scream and Sugar, we unravel the unsettling timeline, examine the victims, and dive into the growing theories that point to something far more sinister lurking along the shores of this beloved nightlife district.

Grab your coffee and your curiosity, and remember to stay spooky, ya'll!

Tags

                                     

https://open.spotify.com/episode/1fOAguINVZ4nbbUmWC51PA?si=1HQSO3CSTuuhLiqSP1BMjw

04/23/2025

02/07/2025

Welcome back spooky squad!

In this episode of Scream and Sugar, we dive into the chilling case of the 2014 Isla Vista murders committed by Elliot Rodger. Through a deep analysis of his manifesto, we explore his warped ideology, the warning signs that were ignored, and the toxic subcultures that fueled his descent into violence. We break down the timeline of events, the investigation that followed, and the broader societal issues surrounding misogyny, entitlement, and mental health. Join us as we sip on some coffee and dissect one of the most infamous crimes of the decade and the lasting impact it left behind. Part II out soon!

Remember to Stay Spooky, ya'll!

Case Notes (all hyperlinks available in our Spreaker Episode Notes): 

crazy bean coffee:  https://crazybeancoffee.com/
Elliot Rodger Crimes: 
About Isla VistaCrimeGrade - Isla VistaCase Study: The Isla Vista Campus Community Mass MurderCBS - Murder Spree TimelineElliot Rodger's Manifesto PDFChilling report details how Elliot Rodger executed murderous rampage | California | The GuardianLA Times - Elliot Rodger meticulously planned Isla Vista rampage, report saysTen Years After the Isla Vista KillingsPeople - Remembering the 6 student victims of the Isla Vista Killingshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Isla_Vista_killingsIsla Vista massacre: 7 killed, 13 injured - ABC7 Los AngelesBBC - How misogynist killer became "incel hero", 2018"Path to intended violence" model to understand mass violence in the case of Elliot Rodger, Allely and Faccini, 2017Youtube Video - "Retribution"Neurodevelopmental and psychosocial risk factors in serial killers and mass murderers

Tags

                                     

01/31/2025

On this episode of Scream and Sugar, we’re diving into the twisted tale of Belle Gunness—one of America’s most infamous female serial killers, alongside our special guest, Brett Masterson!
Operating under the guise of a lonely widow, she lured unsuspecting men to her Indiana farm with promises of love and fortune. But instead of wedding bells, these suitors met a far more gruesome fate. Was Belle a heartless murderer, motivated by greed and a thirst for blood? Or was there something even more sinister at play? 
Brett, who was born and raised in La Porte, Indiana before moving to Reno will lead us through her life, her crimes, and the shocking discovery that left investigators reeling. 

Did she really die in the mysterious fire that consumed her farm, or did she escape to kill again? Grab your coffee and settle in—it’s going to be a dark one. And remember, stay spooky!

Case Notes: 
Coffee From: Superstitions Java, Reno 
Brett Masterson: Reno musician, Magic the Gathering Nerd, born Indianan.

Tags

                                     

01/17/2025

This week on Scream and Sugar, we’re exploring the shocking case of Darren Mack, a prominent Reno businessman whose seemingly perfect life unraveled in a spiral of violence and betrayal. In 2006, amidst a bitter divorce and custody battle, Darren brutally murdered his estranged wife, Charla Mack, in their home. He then attempted to assassinate the family court judge overseeing their case, unleashing chaos and fear throughout the Reno community.

We’ll take you through the events leading up to this tragic day, the international manhunt that ended with Darren’s arrest in Mexico, and the twists and turns of the trial that followed. How did a successful and respected man reach such a breaking point?

Grab your favorite mug and join us as we sip on tasty beverages from Chrome Coffee Works Reno and dissect this chilling story. Don't forget to stay spooky, ya'll!

Notes: 
Chrome Coffee Works Reno: https://www.instagram.com/chromecoffeeworks/

Tags