12/10/2025
Demon House Haunted Attraction LLC.
The Naughty List
Monongahela, PA
December 7, 2025
The holidays are a time for tradition, for revisiting those objects and activities that put you in a merrier mood. Perhaps you love baking cookies or singing carols or viewing holiday lights or shopping until you drop. Well, for Lily and me, it isn’t Christmas until we enter the icy halls of Demon House. Demon House’s holiday event began years ago as a charity venture, a way to raise funds for a haunt actor in distress. (Charles Dickens would approve.) Since then, Demon House’s Christmas haunt has grown, becoming a beloved fixture on the seasonal calendar. It’s easy to see why – Demon House manages to balance creepy and cozy, sentiment and scares, in a way that’s perfect for the holiday.
Part of this is down to set design. The halls are fully decked from the moment you enter the resident fortuneteller’s tent until you face a final encounter with holiday spirits. There isn’t an inch of Demon House that hasn’t been transformed by lights, holly, and tinsel – often in some hilarious and disgusting ways. (If you’ve ever wanted to see a headless body used as a Christmas ornament, or a hallway full of corpses dressed like the cast of The Nutcracker, now’s your chance.) Even the detonator down in the mines has been swathed in wrapping paper. It’s all very twinkly and often tongue-in-cheek.
Demon House has always served up its horror with a hefty dose of humor, and some of the recent changes and additions to Demon House’s scenes make the transition to Christmas a natural one. This fall, Demon House converted its pallet maze into Scary Book Forest, and the fairy tale whimsy has spread to the manor itself, where we’re greeted by a friendly baker whose spread of Christmas goodies (and disdain for naughty children) reminds us of the story of Hansel and Gretel. Some delightfully creepy props help to sell the story. We’re also treated to Demon House’s gruesome version of Light Up Night (which may be one of the best repurposings of a prop that we’ve seen). The asylum and the clown maze remain as dark and surprising as ever, even with a holiday makeover, while the industrial facility has become Santa’s Workshop, under the dubious supervision of a pair of eccentric elves. A harrowing elevator ride dumps us onto the Island of Misfit Toys, before we venture out into Scary Book Forest and on to an unexpected exorcism. (What would a Demon House Christmas be without an exorcism?) The hauntrunners have really thought about how to transform their haunt for the holidays…and how to turn holiday figures into icons of horror. The consistent theme helps. When we enter the manor, the baker asks if we’ve been naughty or nice (Lily throws me under the bus…or the sleigh…immediately). From that point, nearly every creature we meet poses the same question or warns us about the dangers of being naughty. This consistent storyline weaves through the entire haunt. For instance, we get some graphic and gory examples of what happens if you’ve been bad. (The props are created in-house by the creative team, so you won’t see these gooey, bloody bodies on anyone else’s naughty list.) Of course, we finally get to see the infamous Naughty List and of course, our names are on it. From there, it’s just a matter of time until we have to face our punishment…or, because it’s Christmas, redemption.
The place looks great. The theme is clever. But what really makes this event something of a Christmas miracle is the performances. Demon House excels in creating indelible characters and then finding fiercely talented actors to play them. This starts with a scene that could be a throwaway: Lily and I are read the rules of the haunt by a fortuneteller who’s communing with the Ghost of Christmas Past. Okay, the writing is witty and the use of props and effects to underscore the rules is funny and smart (the stove starts smoking just before the fortuneteller cautions “No smoking”). But her loopy, sinister performance makes this scene memorable. The witchy baker is hilariously practical (if Lily and I misbehave, she’s just going to have to bake us into a pie) and the Light Up Night technician’s enthusiasm is infectious. The asylum offers an abrupt change of pace, courtesy of a grinning “nurse” in elf garb and a genuinely unsettling patient who twitched and stumbled as he echoed our words. (He has tried to be festive – he’s braided twinkle lights into his unkempt beard – but he’s too strange and menacing to be really merry.) The clowns are primed for holiday highjinks. Jingle scampers through the halls like a child high on sugar on Christmas morning while her giggling pal delights in a game of hide-and-seek. They deliver us into the anxious hands of type-A elf, Holly, who’s been charged with checking the list twice. Clearly, Holly has spent years in Santa’s HR department. She tries to be reassuring as she delivers the bad news to us. Her pal Jolly on the other hand is absolutely ecstatic to hand us over for punishment. She’s a fountain of jokes and jabs, threatening to bite us one minute and laughing with (or at) us the next. We run smack into a misfit doll (frankly, we don’t get it – she’s gorgeous) and a giant teddy bear who is both adorable and threatening. And all this happens before we’re released into Scary Book Forest, where the walls are decked with rhymes about Gingerbread Riding Hood, Miss Muffet, and the Three Little Pigs (turns out they were on the naughty list) as well as a set that combines Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater with The Toxic Avenger. The horrific poems are packed with jokes and unexpected twists, speaking to the creativity of the hauntrunners, and this little maze is as full of fun and frights as the house. The creatures that are stirring here are also a hoot, including a vengeful Gingerbread Riding Hood whose movements are perfectly coordinated to the maze’s sound effects. Of course, because we have behaved very badly this year, we find ourselves on the wrong side of jolly ol’ St. Nick. When I plead with him, “Can’t we negotiate this whole ‘naughty list’ thing?”, he pulls out a chainsaw and growls, “Yeah. Let’s negotiate.” Lily and I also run smack into an apparition whose tall, ragged frame is topped with a deer skull. We’d think he was the Wendigo if not for his brightly glowing red nose. We also find our path blocked by a hostile snowman who’s looking for some spare parts. The final scene sends us into Whoville where a funny, manic Who shaman tries to perform an exorcism. She’s charismatic and commanding, offering a weird and wonderful end to our journey.
Demon House is a playful, original attraction whose props and makeup are designed and done in-house. You won’t see their scenes and effects anywhere else. You’ll also find very few places that combine charnel house and charm as effectively. If you’re looking to add a new tradition to your holiday calendar, Demon House will make sure that your days are scary and bright..
COST: $25 but you get $10 off admission if you bring a donation for Toys for Tots – or you can seek out their Groupon.
CONCESSIONS: Yes, you can get hot drinks and other treats at their concessions stand.
OTHER STUFF TO DO: The Demon House shop sells branded merchandise made while you wait. You can also buy amazing hats, ornaments and jewelry. Also onsite: Spooky Treasures wish jewelry and dowsing rods, and Kryptic Kre8tions, with their inventive, creepy dolls. The shops take cash but there is an ATM onsite. There’s also an outdoor theater showing seasonal movies and a cozy fire pit.