Infamous Indy

Infamous Indy True crime stories and other happenings in Indiana.

Sarah "Cindy" White has been incarcerated since 1976, serving a total of 48 years thus far. At the time of her arrest sh...
12/07/2024

Sarah "Cindy" White has been incarcerated since 1976, serving a total of 48 years thus far.
At the time of her arrest she was just barely 18 years old. She is the longest serving female inmate in Indiana History. Cindy was said to have been somewhat of a troubled youth, falling victim to physical and s*xual abuse by her father. She had a paper route, and ended up meeting the Roberson Family. Charles and Carole had four children, and when Cindy delivered their paper she would oftentimes sit and play with them. The children loved Cindy. After finding out a bit of Cindy's history from neighbors, the couple wanted to help and decided to have her become a live in nanny for their 4 children. On the night of December 31st, 1975 a fire ravaged the Roberson's home. All who were inside perished, including the couples four children, 7 year old Michael, 6 year old Dale, 5 year old Gary, and Rita or "Sissy" who was just 4 years old. Cindy was somehow able to escape. She would go on to be found guilty of setting the fire, and was sentenced to 6 consecutive life sentences for her crimes. Why did Cindy start a fire in the first place? Some say she was in love with Mr. Roberson and had become jealous of his wife. Others believe she was being abused by the Roberson's, and used the fire as a means to escape. I will be exploring her case, and all of the theories surrounding it in a 2 part series entitled The Babysitter M*rders: The Cindy White Story. Be on the lookout for it in the coming weeks.

On the evening of November 17th, 1978, Four employees of The Burger Chef restaurant in Speedway, Indiana presumably disa...
12/07/2024

On the evening of November 17th, 1978, Four employees of The Burger Chef restaurant in Speedway, Indiana presumably disappeared.
The victims bodies were found 2 days later in a wooded area in Johnson County. 20 year old Jayne Friedt, 16 year old Daniel Davis, 16 year old Mark Flemmonds, and 18 year old Ruth Ellen Shelton were all found brutally slain. The Speedway police chalked it up to a bunch of kids going for a joyride, even though cash was missing from the safe, the doors were left unlocked, and some of the victims belongings such as coats and purses had been left behind. They opened the store for business the very next morning, compromising the crime scene and losing valuable evidence. This case has been left unsolved for the last 46 years, and still haunts citizens and investigators alike. One question still remains to be answered. What happened on that fateful November night? There have been multiple theories, and even a few confessions since then. There have also been some new developments in this case with many people attesting to the fact that they believe one man is responsible for the slayings.
I will be diving into all of these theories in what will most likely be a 4 part series. Be on the lookout for Indy Unsolved: The Burger Chef Murders in the coming weeks.

The case of Steven Valle and Samantha Sebella. This is case is still ongoing as the perpetrators have yet to be sentence...
11/18/2024

The case of Steven Valle and Samantha Sebella. This is case is still ongoing as the perpetrators have yet to be sentenced. I will post an update once they have their day in court! (Idk what happened to my music lol)

11/17/2024

Hey there Creeps, long time no see!! It has been a very difficult year for me, and in a nutshell I've let my professional life take over my entire existence. Things that I'm passionate about have unfortunately been simmering on the back burner for quite some time now. 😕 With that being said, I'm happy to announce that your favorite Dead Girl is back, and new content will be coming your way! Even though I haven't been filming, I've definitely been writing! So here's what I've been cooking up for you all! Once I'm done filming I will post release dates, so here are some of the stories I will be sharing:

-The Unsolved Murder of Tabbi Raines

-Cairo Jordan: The Boy in the Suitcase

-The Burger Chef Murders (reboot w/ new evidence)

-H.H. Holmes: Capturing A Serial Killer

-Kelly Ann Conway: The Devil Woman of Michigan (conclusion)

-Cindy White: The Babysitter Murders

-Marjorie Jackson's Millions (conclusion)

-Herb Baumeister (update)

-The Elkhart 4

- Steven Valle/Samantha Sebella: Buried Secrets

-The Facebook Live M*rders (Non-Indy)

As you can see this is a mix of unfinished projects, some updates, and even a full on reboot, as well as some brand new content. I will also begin filming some stories that are not based in Indy, for those of you who have asked in the past. I hope that I still have some viewers out there, and I look forward to sharing all of these stories with you!

05/11/2024
Many have heard the story of H.H. Holmes, "America's First Serial Killer". While most of his crimes occurred in Chicago,...
08/22/2023

Many have heard the story of H.H. Holmes, "America's First Serial Killer". While most of his crimes occurred in Chicago, did you know that H.H. Holmes also spent some time right here in Indiana? This would be the last murder he would ever commit, and ultimately it would lead to his capture, confession, and death. I've had this one brewing for quite some time now!!! Thank you to my long time friend and follower, Scott Carlson for the story suggestion!

Marjorie Jackson was the widow of Chester Jackson. Chester Jackson was a very eccentric man, and the owner of the Standa...
08/21/2023

Marjorie Jackson was the widow of Chester Jackson. Chester Jackson was a very eccentric man, and the owner of the Standard Grocery chain, which had about 250 locations throughout Indiana during this time. After his untimely death, his wife Marjorie stood to inherit his fortune. It's said that one of Chester's many quirks was that he did not trust banks. This led him to hide huge amounts of money all throughout his home. A habit his wife Marjorie continued, after having seven hundred thousand dollars stolen from one of her personal accounts. A known hermit of sorts, Marjorie began leaving her property on Spring Mill Road to make periodic trips to the bank. With suitcases and grocery bags in hand, she withdrew 500,000 to one million at a time in stscks of one hundred dollar bills. Within 4 months she had withdrew the entirety of her 9 million dollar account. She then began to withdraw the rest of her money from other accounts that remained open as well. Rumors began to swirl about the widow on Spring Mill Road with her fortune hidden throughout her home. She became a regular target for robberies, some of which she never even bothered to report.
On May 7th, 1977 she was robbed once again, and this time she would end up losing her life.

08/21/2023

Part 2 of Marjorie Jackson's Millions.

I am now on tiktok! Be sure to follow! 😁
08/07/2023

I am now on tiktok! Be sure to follow! 😁

08/06/2023

Not sure what happened with the music, but I'm not gonna be too hard on myself. Take it easy on me, it's my first ticky-tocky 😂😂😂 still figuring out how everything works

https://youtu.be/Ra_pdCa1sxI
05/22/2023

https://youtu.be/Ra_pdCa1sxI

In January of 2023, Oaklee Snow and her older brother were taken from their father's home in Oklahoma by their Mother Madison Marshall without consent. Madis...

Kelly M. Cochran is an alleged serial murderer, suspected of killing at least 10 people. She is most well known for the ...
05/19/2023

Kelly M. Cochran is an alleged serial murderer, suspected of killing at least 10 people. She is most well known for the crimes against her husband, Jason Cochran. Kelly had found out about Jason's extramarital affairs and decided to take matters into her own hands. She injected Jason with a lethal dose of he**in, before smothering him with a pillow. To make matters worse, she allegedly served up his remains to unsuspecting neighbors at a barbecue. Be on the lookout for her story in the coming weeks.

In April of 2023, the body of 2 year old Oaklee Snow was found on an abandoned property in Morgantown, Indiana. Oaklee a...
05/19/2023

In April of 2023, the body of 2 year old Oaklee Snow was found on an abandoned property in Morgantown, Indiana. Oaklee and her older brother Coleton had been taken from the care of their Father Zachary in Oklahoma sometime in January. Madison Marshall (mother) and her boyfriend Roan Waters led police on a search across 4 states, with the tragedy ending right here in Indy. The two had left Coleton in a trap house they had been smoking he**in in, but what happened to little Oaklee was even worse. Tune in this week as I break down the timeline of Oaklees Disappearance, as well as what transpired during, and after.

Address

Indianapolis, IN

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Infamous Indy posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Infamous Indy:

Videos

Share

Category