01/28/2023
To finish off Pixar week I wanted to look at the latest release that is not connected to the Toy Story universe. This is film is part of the trend that Pixar has lately with films focusing on human characters while this was something that wasn’t as common before 2017. While centering around something that was controversial, it should be looked at as its own film and ignore all the noise surrounding it.
Turning Red
This film did great with introducing concepts, but not so well with following through on them. They made a point in this film to address subject matter that may not be a easy to discuss for younger viewers, but it was done in a way that makes it receptive to them. The animation is always amazing as we continue to see in Pixar films. It hurts the film where so much work was done to animate this film and go over some uncomfortable concepts, but the ending falls flat. All of the resolutions to conflict are completely rushed and poorly written. This makes what could have been an impressive and memorable film into one that leaves you disappointed.
Rating: 5/10
Monday Morning Director: Turning Red
SPOILERS BELOW!!
Disclaimer:
The term Monday morning coach refers to individuals that act as if they have all the answers the day after the game and provide none on Sunday, the day of the game. The information presented is not to insult those who contributed to the making of this film, but to provide an analysis of what could have been done given the knowledge beforehand. I do not know the difficulties the individuals making this film went through, so I make this disclaimer beforehand to show my respect for those in the industry that put in their time making this film.
There was a great design to the characters and setting that should be acknowledged first. Pixar has shown they are great with rendering furry animals ever since Monsters Inc so the fact that Mei as a red panda looked great was no surprise. It always amazes me how expressive Pixar animals and creatures are with just their faces even when they have to do so much with just the animation of the body in general. It feels like Pixar was animating an anime at times with the numerous references to anime tropes. You see how the eyes change for characters when they see something cute or the animation that comes after Mei makes her final hit on her mother’s panda form. I like those nods to that genre since it is something that deserves recognition while it also works because it is centered around an Asian family.
The message is one that is very uncommon in a family film, and it is a welcome one to help dialogue with parents and their children. The film is not afraid to bring up the taboo concept of a female growing into womanhood and all that entails. They bring up the use of pads and how natural it is. While this is all that discussed regarding specifics about a woman and her period, it is a great launching point for discussion for families and for any girl that may have questions. They still move forward with the awkward social and psychological moments that comes with puberty. She is overcome with more intense emotions towards boys, and it seems to take over her in certain moments. Normally it would be strange to focus on one of the boys in school during the film with no reference to him later, but this is appropriate for reflecting the mindset of Mei during this time in her life. Her mother is also having to contend with her personally changes, though she isn't as accepting of her becoming her own person. This film's main focus should have been the complicated nature of the relationship between a mother and daughter but representing different issues of that relationship than what was shown in Brave.
The conflict feels very forced in multiple parts of the film. The biggest issue comes when Mei rejects her friends when her mother shames them at Tyler’s party. It felt like a cheap way to add tension to the end of the film without a satisfying setup. The conflict between her and her friends wasn’t ever brought up. Whenever they had any conflict, they worked together to find a resolution. This was a great example of how a healthy friendship is supposed to work. Almost right after Mei forced the divide with her friends, she came back in and all was forgiven. This is why it felt cheap and meaningless to have this conflict between them ever happen. A better way to move this plot forward is that Mei stands up for her friends and says that she wanted to come to the party. Her mother’s response would be denial that her daughter would do this out of her own volution and accuse her friends of warping her mind while taking her away. This would cause her mother to force the separation between her and her friends without it feeling cheap. This would also feed into the conflict with Mei and her mother so it can be a better payoff at the end.
The ending didn’t work as well because none of the resolutions felt earned. The writers push a resolution between Mei and her mother right at the end when the mother was given no time to redeem herself prior to their talk at the end of the film. She appears as someone who goes overboard with how she treats her daughter and her husband. She only goes more extreme from there. It takes you out of the film because of how far she goes to be in her child’s business and interrupt her life. She shows off perverse drawings her daughter made of a boy to that boy and also breaks into school to spy on her daughter and hand her pads in front of her class. This goes way past reason, even for a silly animated film. It makes her completely unlikeable without giving off the idea that is still a good person. It gets to the point where she becomes a Kaiju and literally attacks her own daughter. Instead of coming to a resolution Mei just knocks her out. This is when we have out been resolution between the two. This is not how you make the antagonist sympathetic. By making violence the only means to calm her, she was essentially made into a villain instead of just an antagonist. Following this up with her just making up with Mei after a brief conversation about her changing makes this too quick of a pull back to center. There was also a reconciliation between the mother and grandmother that came out of nowhere. It seemed like an offhand joke at first when the grandmother called and the mother didn’t want to respond to her. There is tension between them when they are together briefly and the only semblance of the background was given in exposition by the father later in the film. This leads up to another weak resolution that just compounds the one with the other two earlier. They show a resolution between the girls and Tyler just because he was at the 4*Town concert which is again, rushed and unsatisfactory. They should have just had something silly happen to him where he got karmic justice without it ever involving the girls whatsoever. It could have been something simple like him getting upset that he isn’t getting their attention anymore and makes a fool of himself at school. It never felt like the resolutions were important to the writers so ones were hastily done to get to the end of the film.