11/30/2025
FULL INTERVIEW: ADIRONDACK MURDERS RE-EXAMINED, EVIDENCE REVIEW SHOWS LIKELY-LINK TO UNSOLVED CNY COLD CASE
Certain sensitive details were re-examined recently as part of a focus into a notorious Central New York cold case that remains under investigation by the New York State Police. Two of the area's top legal experts sat down with Fulton County Area News as part of an effort to review several key portions of the 1973 murder spree by Adirondack Killer Robert F. Garrow Sr of Syracuse.
Top Defense Attorneys Bob Abdella and Joe Sise of Abdella & Sise LLP took part in an on-camera interview as part of an in-depth look into what is now identified as a likelihood that Garrow could have been connected to the 1973 mysterious death of 21 year old Martha Louise Allen of Oneida County. Allen was found dead in a remote area near Oneida Lake in the Town of Verona northwest of Turning Stone Casino. A cause of death could not be determined due to advanced decomposition according to police reports. Allen disappeared on July 25th, 1973. Her body was discovered more than three weeks later floating in Black Creek near Sterling and Poppleton Roads just east of Verona Beach State Park. Involvement by Garrow has not been ruled out according to a source close to the Allen case.
Garrow has also been pinpointed by experts in the July 1973 disappearance of teenage concert goers Bonnie Bikwit and Mitchel Weiser. The pair were hitchhiking to Summer Jam, a massive rock concert that drew over 600,000 people to Watkins Glen, NY. The case comntinues to draw national attention through ongoing efforts by Rolling Stone Magazine's Eric Greenberg.
During their November 2025 interview Attorneys Abdella and Sise were joined by Fulton County Sheriff Richard C. Giardino to set forth an effort to closely examine various evidence and offer a related legal-review. The Garrow case included the discovery of a mysterious map that retired New York State Police Investigators could only later describe as a likely link to additional crimes. Garrow was confirmed though his own admissions to have killed at least four people with three of the murders involving young campers in the Adirondacks. At one time Investigators suspected Garrow with involvement in as many as more than twenty related cases. To date and after more than fifty years a portion of the Garrow case remains sealed by a 1974 Hamilton County Court order.
Part-two of this series will include a closer look at certain evidence that could link Garrow to the Allen case.
© Video by Fulton County Area News