29/08/2022
What Distinguishes Attempted or Frustrated Homicide from Physical Injuries?
To distinguish them, the first thing that we have to look is into the nature of the wound inflicted. Ascertain whether the wound is slight or mortal. Slight wound means the wound is not sufficient to cause death. Mortal wound on the other hand means the wound is sufficient to cause death. After we determined the the nature of the wound, we have to ascertain whether the infliction of the wound is with or without intent to kill. If the infliction of the wound is with intent to kill, then the crime committed is attempted homicide. On the other hand, if the infliction of the wound is without intent to kill, then the crime committed is slight or less serious physical injuries.
Now if the wound is mortal, same thing we have to ascertain whether the infliction of the wound is with or without intent to kill. If it is inflicted with intent to kill, then the crime committed is frustrated homicide. On the other hand, if it is inflicted without intent to kill, then the crime committed is serious physical injuries.
Now the question is, how can we ascertain intent to kill considering that intent is merely confined to the mind of the person? Intent to kill is ascertained by looking at the external action of the person. It can be determined by the nature of the weapon used or the manner the wound is inflicted. Example, if the accused shot the victim directly at the abdomen, he cannot claim that his intent is to inflict mere physical injuries. Shooting the person directly at the abdomen is reasonable to cause death.
That’s what distinguishes attempted/frustrated homicide from physical injuries.