
13/03/2025
Why did the startup business owner hire an SEO agency? Because they wanted to rank #1 on Google for "How to waste money fast." 😆
I'm serious though.
J'accuse the entire worldwide SEO and PPC industry of ripping off small and startup businesses!
Remember my recent takedown of SEO and PPC last week? Well, what can I say? I expected an army of enraged SEO and PPC lads charging at me, ready to defend their sacred cows.
Instead? Silence ...
Not a single credible rebuttal.
Not even a half-hearted “Well, actually…” from the SEO & PPC bros. And that, dear friends, makes them culpable.
They know I’m right.
So, let’s go deeper.
This is Part II of my "J'accuse," where I expose the real reason SEO & PPC “experts” won’t engage, backed by case studies, cold hard data, and the tragic financial ruins of those who fell for their scams.
Quite frankly, I am sick and tired of hearing about small business owners losing their life savings having invested in all-singing-and-dancing websites with eye-watering levels of SEO / PPC packages attached.
(FYI, let's get the terminology straight - SEO = Search Engine Optimised and PPC = Pay Per Click and usually refers to Google Ads).
*The SEO & PPC Industrial Complex: A Scheme Built on Small Business Corpses*
SEO agencies and PPC experts need you to believe they hold the keys to digital success. Their entire industry thrives on the illusion that without their “special” skills, your business is doomed to obscurity.
But let’s be real: If SEO was as powerful as they claim, why are their own client acquisition strategies based on cold emails, LinkedIn spam, and desperate DMs?
If PPC was so magical, why do PPC agencies rely on referrals, email outreach, and networking, instead of their own ads?
I’ll tell you why: Because they know SEO & PPC don’t work for small businesses!
Yes, SEO and PPC WILL work if you have plenty of time and a big budget to play with - let's say 6 to 18 months - but for 99% of small or startup businesses, they cannot compete so should never be expected to do so!
*Case Study #1: The SEO Pyramid Scheme*
James, an immigration lawyer, was promised “steady organic leads” if he just stuck with SEO long enough.
He hired an SEO agency for £3,500/month.
12 months later, he was ranking slightly higher … but no leads.
The agency told him, “SEO is a long-term game, give it another six months.”
He did. Still no leads.
He fired them, built a strong LinkedIn video strategy, and landed 5 clients within 60 days.
📈 Cost of SEO: £42,000 flushed into the abyss.
📈 Cost of LinkedIn videos made on his mobile phone: £0 (and it actually worked)!
*Case Study #2: The Google Ads Dumpster Fire, Reloaded*
Emma, a Change Consultant, ran Google Ads for 3 months. Here’s what happened:
She spent £6,000
Got 450 clicks
Received 30 inquiries
25 of them were price shoppers or looking for free advice
Closed zero deals
Meanwhile, her competitor used a SEO-based talking head video with a valuable freebie lead magnet and referral system then landed 10 high-value clients with zero ad spend
🤑 Google Ads ROI: Minus £6,000
🤑 Referral-based marketing ROI: Plus £40,000 in closed deals
*The SEO & PPC Industry’s Dirty Little Secrets*
- The “Long Game” Myth: They always say, “SEO takes time.” You know what else takes time? Burning through your life savings while waiting for clients who never appear! When you're a small or startup business, ain't nobody got time to wait for you to hit page 1 of a Google Search, especially when you're competing with deep pocket competitors going after those same keywords!
- They Profit, Even If You Lose: SEO & PPC agencies charge monthly retainers. Whether you get leads or not, they get paid!
- The Click-Through Rate Delusion: A PPC agency will flex that “your CTR is up 250%!” But what they won’t tell you? CTR doesn’t pay your bills. You need conversions, not clicks. And 9 times out of 10 those clicks came from THE WRONG TARGET AUDIENCE! I don't want to tell you about the number of businesses who were comfortable with the amount of website traffic they received despite none of it converting. Why? Because that was a luxury jewellery company with 20,000 website clicks coming from people in Bangladesh / Argentina / Albania who like tech, websites and shipping.
*What Actually Works Instead?*
1. Short-Form Video & Social Content
80% of online traffic is video (Forbes, 2024)
TikTok & LinkedIn videos generate 3x more engagement than static posts
Video makes potential clients feel like they know you (which means easier sales)
2. Email Sequences That Convert
75% of website visitors leave and never return (HubSpot, 2024)
Automated email nurturing increases sales by 70% (Campaign Monitor, 2023)
And unlike SEO, email actually brings in real leads
3. Referral & Reputation Marketing
90% of buyers trust reviews as much as personal recommendations (BrightLocal, 2024)
A 5-star rating increases conversion rates by 270%
If you have more & better reviews than your competitors, clients choose you, without SEO
4. Networking & Relationship-Based Selling
84% of B2B decision-makers start their search through recommendations (LinkedIn, 2024)
Referral leads close 4x faster than cold leads (Forbes, 2023)
You can literally double your revenue without spending a penny on ads
Final Thought: The SEO & PPC Bros’ Silence Is Deafening
If my first article was wrong, why didn’t they fight back?
If SEO & PPC were the gods of marketing, where’s the proof that it works better than relationship-driven selling, referrals, and social video marketing?
*Something to think about.*
Instead of pouring money into the Google black hole, use strategies that actually bring in paying clients.
📢 Join Me for "Digital Sales Excellence - A Masterclass in Digital Marketing" in collaboration with Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce
📅 20th March 2025
⏰ 10:00 - 12:00 Online
🎫 For members and non-members
You’ll walk away with a plug-and-play system to turn strangers into paying clients, without throwing money at SEO or Google Ads.
🎟️ Book your spot before your competitors do. 🎟️
🔗 Book Here https://www.edinburghchamber.co.uk/events/digital-sales-excellence-a-masterclass-in-digital-marketing/?eid=FD871363-32AB-4ECC-B70D-6E4DCEAD20C0&type=Training
Supporting and empowering the business community in Edinburgh and beyond to prosper, grow and achieve success.