09/12/2024
Review: Black Doves (Netflix)
Full transparency: I am loving this. Sure, Episode 3 is weak in my opinion—certainly the first half. Ironically, given what I’m about to write about the relationship at the heart of the series, Episode 3 is about that very relationship and how it developed over the years. But that aside, read on.
Black Doves is an ambitious dive into the spy-thriller genre, carried on the shoulders of two standout leads, Keira Knightley and Ben Whishaw. While the series boasts intriguing characters and occasional moments of brilliance, it falters in delivering a truly groundbreaking narrative. For a show that sets itself up as a fresh take on espionage, it often leans too heavily on well-worn genre tropes.
At its core, Black Doves shines brightest when exploring the platonic yet deeply layered relationship between Knightley’s Helen and Whishaw’s Sam. This pairing is the heart of the series—bringing warmth, tension, and unpredictability to an otherwise formulaic political conspiracy plot. Their dynamic is a refreshing departure from the tired romantic subplots that often plague similar stories. It’s in these quieter, character-driven moments where the series truly finds its voice.
From a production standpoint, Black Doves excels in atmosphere. The festive London backdrop adds a unique, almost ironic cheer to the murky dealings of spies and assassins. The cinematography captures this duality beautifully, creating a setting that feels alive and purposeful. However, the pacing is inconsistent; the first episodes meander, while the finale feels like a rushed attempt to tie loose ends and set up a second season.
The script has moments of sharpness, particularly in its comedic beats, which are rare for the genre and provide a welcome sense of levity. However, these moments highlight a deeper issue: the series struggles to decide what it wants to be. Is it a character study? A political thriller? A caper with heart? The tonal shifts, while interesting, leave the story feeling unfocused.
For industry professionals, the series is a study in the power of casting and chemistry. Knightley and Whishaw elevate every scene they’re in, demonstrating how strong leads can anchor a project even when the material isn’t always firing on all cylinders. From a format perspective, Black Doves has potential—it introduces enough intrigue and likable characters to justify a return. The challenge for future seasons will be refining its identity and finding a stronger throughline for its overarching plot.
Verdict: Black Doves is worth watching for its stellar performances and unique take on character relationships within a spy thriller. However, it’s not the genre-defining series it aspires to be—at least, not yet. With more focus and better pacing, it could grow into something truly special.