
01/07/2025
A fascinating debut novel from Susie Dent, renowned lexicographer and doyenne of Channel 4's 'Countdown'. And given her background and speciality, what else should she write about but a group of Oxford lexicographers working on the ever-evolving 'Clarendon English Dictionary' (the OED by any other name ...) There is however a twisty, turny murder mystery thrown in, as Martha Thornhill, returning to her native Oxford from a stint in Berlin, is confronted along with her colleagues by a series of cryptic messages from someone signing off as 'The Chorus', all seemingly referring to the disappearance of her sister Charlie 13 years ago.
The messages are mostly composed of Shakespearean quotes, which at least gives the team a starting point ... but what, exactly, was promising PhD student Charlie working on at the time of her disappearance, and why are these clues only surfacing now?
It's a really gripping read, and my only reservations relate to the obscurity of the messages- as someone who's hopeless at crosswords, I really couldn't follow some of the decoding processes and just had to take them on trust - and Dent's overkill when it comes to inserting and explaining the meanings of obscure words. Some of these are very relevant to the narrative, and it was fun discovering them, but others seemed to have been inserted rather clumsily just for the hell of it - an understandable indulgence for a lexicographer, but to me it did seem to be overegging the pudding somewhat.
Nevertheless, 'Guilty by Definition' gets a hearty recommendation from me for anyone interested in words!