18/03/2023
MY REVIEW/OPINION of Bloomfield Township's meeting:
3/16/23 WATER/SEWER study session: a "dog and pony show"?
Many people attended and spoke during public comment. Also, some spoke/shouted out of turn (probably frustrated) because the issues were not well understood by many nor fully explained by the Board except to say something about "having many previous meetings about this.." The meeting finally ended at 9:45 pm I would say MOST people never knew about any of the previous "meetings".
HISTORY:
The Board of Trustees last year approved changing how w/s RATES were going to be determined. They added size of the PIPE/Meter to determine rates. The bigger the pipe, the higher the rate. Also, at that time, they did decide to wait on whether or not to also charge a fee for the secondary water meters for this fiscal year 2023-2024. So, fast forward, it is NOW time to decide on that FEE. Thus the study session, in part.
ISSUE #1
Before the actual study session on 3/16/23 the Township mailed (to ONLY those having secondary meters) a postcard notice informing them of the meeting. Why not informing ALL RESIDENTS ? I will guess that the Township had heard from many residents about the idea of charging a fee for the
secondary meter and was somehow suggesting "grandfathering" those with
existing secondary meters from the fee and only charging any NEW secondary meter installations. MANY people spoke at public comment about the ridiculous idea of charging a FEE for that secondary meter and asked for the "grandfathering" of their meter from the fee. HOWEVER, it is a BAD idea PERIOD. PAY FOR WATER USAGE.... not for meter size or number of.... but for USAGE. At next month April meeting, the Board will decide on FEE issue for secondary meters. Will it just be FEE? or perhaps "grandfathering?" or NO FEE even for any potential NEW installs? TBD.
ISSUES #3 AND #3
Two other issues at the Study Session that the Water/Sewer department head was seeking input about was about HOW SHOULD he set the RATES to pay for the "Emergency" repairs and secondly, the "Costs" for the water meter replacement program. Should he figure in the approximately $4 MILLION cost for "emergencies" and $3 MILLION cost for the first year meter replacement contract in the RATES??? or could he budget those costs by USING MONEY FROM the Water/Sewer FUND BALANCE ? by the way, there is $20 MILLION in RESERVE FUNDS already collected from the w/s users.
Again, OMG. Should he even need to ask? If there is $20 MILLION dollars sitting in a bank earning practically no interest, OF COURSE USE THAT MONEY! A third choice was to get BONDS to pay for those costs? STUPID to pay fees for that to happen and also add additional interest fees for 20 years. While the Board could not vote at a Study Session, it appears that at the April 2023 meeting they will vote to use Reserve Funds and NOT use those figures in rate settings.
But, a Board member wants information about costs for bonding. OMG.
Why? because there is another up to $6 million in the already approved contract to be completed in the future two years.
FYI: Subtract the $7 million from the existing $20 million and there will still be $13 MILLION in Reserve Funds. Use the MONEY IN THE BANK.
QUESTION:
Last September 12, 2022 the Board approved $300,000 for the Water Meter replacement program and the contract for 2022-2023. That money was already in the budget. However, at the 3/16/23 Study Session I heard nothing about how or IF that $300,000 was spent in fiscal year 2022-2023 to that approved contractor. Was the $300,000 spent and how?
QUESTION: how much money is REALLY needed in 2023-2024 to perform work by this company? How many meters/lead inspections/cellular end hook ups. etc. can they possibly get to in the fiscal year? All 18,000 homes? That company should be able to project that figure to the Board of how many can be replaced so that a reasonable dollar amount for RESERVE money is requested at the April 2023 meeting on Water/Sewer Rates/Budget.
MORE HISTORY.... very GOOD... recommend taking the time to review the AUDIO/VIDEO where the Board and the Dept. Head discussed approving the Meter Replacement contract back in September of 2022.
LINKS: 9/12/22 MINUTES of meeting:
that includes LINKS to audio/video of meeting
and also includes the LINK to the details in the "board packet" of that meeting
https://bloomfieldtwpmi.documents-on-demand.com/?l=0d43a2a4190944e59d3b642c85ae3983&r=EBB14D6E37647C381C172E81917FE164&d=c55ff307cc44ed11a392000c29a59557
AND
Public Comment from 9/12/22 BEFORE the vote then to have a $8 million dollar meter replacement contract.... Comes right after the Pledge. Need to watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bUGD966uHFU
In an attempt to better serve you, this page will allow you to view the agendas, packets and minutes for Bloomfield Township's boards and commissions. Due to the size of some of the documents, upload times will vary. We appreciate your patience.