My Comic Shop History

  • Home
  • My Comic Shop History

My Comic Shop History Podcast hosted by Anthony Desiato exploring the culture of the comics retail industry. Available on

My Comic Shop History may have signed off for good (still holding to that, by the way, despite what Steve Oto thinks 😆),...
14/06/2024

My Comic Shop History may have signed off for good (still holding to that, by the way, despite what Steve Oto thinks 😆), but have you listened to my Superman podcast? We’re over 150 episodes in, are currently in the midst of extensive Superboy coverage, and—this coming Tuesday—will be welcoming Superboy TV actor Gerard Christopher as a guest! AR alumni Rich Roney, Bill Maio, Mike Sangregorio, & more have all been guests over the years. 🎧 & sub! Wherever you get podcasts.

"Hello, I must be going." Jay Meisel passed away peacefully this morning. I know Jay would say not to make this too % #@...
20/02/2024

"Hello, I must be going."

Jay Meisel passed away peacefully this morning. I know Jay would say not to make this too % #@^ing depressing, so I'll try my best.

How many people do you meet in a lifetime? How many can you TRULY say are larger than life—a character in every sense of the word? That was Jay. (Jay, by the way, was his full name. Not short for anything!)

A man out of time, who decried modern technology and the lack of appreciation for the films & music of the past. A curmudgeon barking at everyone who came his way, his gruffness belying his sweet interior. He was funny, politically incorrect, and unaware, I think, of just how appreciated he was. Jay had a way, with a smile and twinkle in his eye, of making you feel like you were in on a joke that no one else knew about.

Jay, you let me tell your story (a few times over), and I cherish those times more than anyone can know. You called my podcasts "controlled bullsh!t," and I laugh every time I think of that. Any time I curse at a bad driver in Yiddish, you're with me. Seriously, if Milo's first bad word isn't "schmuck," I'll be shocked.

Rest easy now, my friend. And don't worry: If anyone calls the site of your longstanding comics booth the "FLEA market," I'll tell 'em to % #@^ off, because I know you detest the word "flea."

Zei gezunt.

Jay Meisel: October 20, 1936 — February 20, 2024.

Sad that My Comic Shop History is over? There’s an Alternate Realities reunion to enjoy TODAY on the latest Digging for ...
28/11/2023

Sad that My Comic Shop History is over? There’s an Alternate Realities reunion to enjoy TODAY on the latest Digging for Kryptonite: A Superman Fan Journey, where Rich “Friendship & Fun” Roney joins me for a very fun Silver Age Superman discussion! Give it a listen.

☄️ SILVER AGE COMIC TALK with Rich Roney! On this week’s 🎙️ Digging for Kryptonite🎙️, the “Doomed Planet” podcast event continues as one of our favorite guests returns to survey a selection of Pre-Crisis stories featuring the Bottle (or Bottled? 😉) City of Kandor.

Among many others, we discuss: "The Super-Duel in Space" (ACTION #242), "Superman in Kandor" (SUPERMAN #158), and “The Feud Between Batman and Superman!" (WORLD'S FINEST #143), aka the first comic book Rich ever bought and read at 8 years old! It’s a very fun tour through Pre-Crisis Kandor with a guest who lived through all of these stories back in the day.

What are YOUR favorite Kandor stories? How many look-alikes is too many? And does the presence of so many Kryptonians on Earth (albeit in bottled form) diminish Superman to any degree for you? Listen, enjoy, and share your answers to these questions!

🎧 now wherever you podcasts. Link in bio.

🚨 SERIES FINALE ALERT! 🚨 In 2015, I started this podcast to say goodbye to Alternate Realities, the comic shop that had ...
01/11/2023

🚨 SERIES FINALE ALERT! 🚨 In 2015, I started this podcast to say goodbye to Alternate Realities, the comic shop that had been like a second home to me for many years. That first time behind the 🎙️ was the start to a journey that has taken me to places & introduced me to people I couldn’t have foreseen. It’s meant the world to me, but everything has its season, and now:

The time has come to bid My Comic Shop History farewell in this special, supersized SERIES FINALE event. Join Steve Oto, Rich Roney, Bill Maio, and yours truly for one last AR reunion—a 3-hour extravaganza filled with surprises, expressions of love & gratitude, our best stories revisited, shout-outs aplenty, and a customer “draft” not to be missed.

Thanks to EVERYONE who has been part of the journey in any way. Endings can be bittersweet, but that’s not a bad thing. I love the way we went out in this episode. Hope you do too.

🎧 now whether you get podcasts. No flat squirrels here.

Since 2015, I’ve hosted the podcast 🎙️ MY COMIC SHOP HISTORY. And now, it’s time to sign off. One week from today, join ...
25/10/2023

Since 2015, I’ve hosted the podcast 🎙️ MY COMIC SHOP HISTORY. And now, it’s time to sign off. One week from today, join us the series finale of My Comic Shop History. Stores close & podcasts end, but friendship & fun last forever. Don’t miss it.

Stopped by the site of the old clubhouse today. Feeling nostalgic as the series finale recording approaches this weekend...
19/10/2023

Stopped by the site of the old clubhouse today. Feeling nostalgic as the series finale recording approaches this weekend. Hear it one week from today! If you have anything to share about this journey before it concludes, it’s now or never to speak up!

11/10/2023

Our SERIES FINALE recording is nigh! If you have ANY final comments/Qs, drop 'em below. Thank you all.

🎙️ NEW EPISODE ALERT! Folks, it’s time for the penultimate episode of My Comic Shop History, recorded live in studio wit...
13/07/2023

🎙️ NEW EPISODE ALERT! Folks, it’s time for the penultimate episode of My Comic Shop History, recorded live in studio with guest RICH RONEY of “friendship and fun” fame. Available NOW wherever you get podcasts!

In the Summer installment of our “For All Seasons” farewell event, Rich & I:

😢 relive the dismantling of The Store;
📦 discuss how hu***ng long boxes is akin to digging coal;
🇺🇸 recap a small gathARing over Memorial Day weekend;
🤓 assess the state of Rich's comic book reading; and
🎟️ share a disappointing change of plans regarding an AR reunion at TerrifiCon.

Seriously, does anyone need a Friday ticket for TerrifiCon?!

PLUS! The ongoing saga of Rich Roney vs. Technology reaches its most outrageous turn yet. I was flabbergasted during the last 20 minutes or so of the episode.

Enjoy. 🎧 Series finale this Fall! Don’t miss any of our farewell run.

Just what did Rich Roney say during today’s My Comic Shop History recording (our penultimate episode ever!) to elicit th...
02/07/2023

Just what did Rich Roney say during today’s My Comic Shop History recording (our penultimate episode ever!) to elicit this response? For those who have been following the saga of Rich Roney vs. Technology all these years, you do NOT want to miss this. Coming soon!

Many Happy Returns to Steve Oto, the legendary co-founder and former owner of Alternate Realities! Did you catch his app...
17/06/2023

Many Happy Returns to Steve Oto, the legendary co-founder and former owner of Alternate Realities! Did you catch his appearance on the Spring episode of My Comic Shop History? Cue it up if you missed it last month!

Our Summer installment drops in July with returning guest Rich Roney. And if you’re a Superman fan, I hope you’ve been listening to Digging for Kryptonite: A Superman Fan Journey!

AR Reunion - MDW ‘23REMINDER that the first two chapters of the My Comic Shop History farewell event (Winter with Dr. Bi...
28/05/2023

AR Reunion - MDW ‘23

REMINDER that the first two chapters of the My Comic Shop History farewell event (Winter with Dr. Bill & Spring with SKO) are available now. Two down, two to go!

🎊 MY COMIC SHOP HISTORY RETURNS! What, did you think we were going to send you into Free Comic Book Day without the man ...
05/05/2023

🎊 MY COMIC SHOP HISTORY RETURNS! What, did you think we were going to send you into Free Comic Book Day without the man behind the epic “Freeloader Day” rant?

Steve Oto is once again behind the mic—in person!—for the second of the final four episodes of My Comic Shop History. In the Spring installment of “For All Seasons,” Steve & I discuss a recent comic shop resurrection in the Westchester area, a long-awaited update on a beloved AR figure (including a precious voice cameo), the many changes in Steve's life, and more!

🎧 via the platforms below or wherever else you get podcasts 👇

🍎 https://apple.co/3AWloOH
🟢 https://spoti.fi/41bWdCa

Only two episodes of My Comic Shop History remain! Rich Roney will be here for the Summer episode, and then all four of us will come together for the swan song this Fall.

28/03/2023

Recording the Spring episode with STEVE OTO very soon! Have you 🎧 to the Winter episode yet?

NEW PLATFORM ALERT: The documentary film MY COMIC SHOP COUNTRY is now also available on Tubi! If you're not familiar, Tu...
02/03/2023

NEW PLATFORM ALERT: The documentary film MY COMIC SHOP COUNTRY is now also available on Tubi! If you're not familiar, Tubi is a free, ad-supported platform—no account even required to watch. If you STILL haven't seen the doc after 3 years, (A) congrats, you're a flat squirrel* 😉, and (B) this is a great new option.

Tubi caps video quality at 720p, and again, there are ads, so Apple TV and Amazon remain the best ways (IMO) to watch. But I'm very happy to have the film accessible via this new platform as well for more folks to discover.

WATCH HERE: https://tubitv.com/movies/715531/my-comic-shop-country

*Speaking of flat squirrels, if you're a Superman fan (even, like, a little bit), you MUST check out Digging for Kryptonite: A Superman Fan Journey. Hope you enjoy if you do, and thanks to everyone who has already joined us on that podcast—which, by the way, is fast approaching Episode 100!

Finally, are y'all following "For All Seasons," My Comic Shop History's quarterly farewell event? Part 1 with Bill Maio is out now, and SKO himself will be back for Part 2 this Spring. It's the final 4 episodes!

Ladies & gentlemen, the one & only JAY MEISEL. I recently had the opportunity to connect with Jay in person for the firs...
14/02/2023

Ladies & gentlemen, the one & only JAY MEISEL. I recently had the opportunity to connect with Jay in person for the first time in 3 years. He is currently suffering from dementia & living at a rehabilitation center in CT. Despite his diminished capacity, he still recognized me, carried on a conversation for over 2 hours, and retained his trademark (albeit dulled) Jay style.

There were numerous expressions of love & gratitude both ways, and I will forever cherish the opportunity to hug him and tell him how much of an impression he made on me.

The afternoon zipped by: we caught up, watched the By Spoon! bloopers, read some audience comments from YouTube, & FaceTimed with SKO.

Most of all, I told him over & over how many people have asked about him—from the AR & flea market alumni to strangers who saw the docs—and it moved him to tears.

Thanks to everyone who’s asked about Jay. It’s definitely appreciated.

🚨 THE FINAL RUN BEGINS! Alternate Realities legend Bill Maio joins me for Chapter One of “For All Seasons,” our quarterl...
02/02/2023

🚨 THE FINAL RUN BEGINS! Alternate Realities legend Bill Maio joins me for Chapter One of “For All Seasons,” our quarterly farewell event. In our ❄️ installment, we share our thoughts on the state of the industry and our community almost a decade after AR went up to that big back issue big in the sky. Listen wherever you get podcasts, enjoy, and come back this Spring for the long-awaited return of SKO.

Ft. art by Philtastic Phil & music by Ralph Puma!

THIS THURSDAY! “For All Seasons,” the My Comic Shop History farewell event (for good this time!) begins with our Winter ...
30/01/2023

THIS THURSDAY! “For All Seasons,” the My Comic Shop History farewell event (for good this time!) begins with our Winter installment and guest Bill Maio. Before the event is done, you’ll hear from Rich Roney and Steve Oto as well. This is really it, folks:

After the new comic days…after the dinners…after the final night under those fluorescent lights…

There was the Alternate Realities gang, a community considering the legacy of The Store that brought us all together.

It’s the final My Comic Shop History event in a story told across the four seasons of the year. I hope you’ll join us, and thank you for your support over the years.

Very sad to see our friends at The Spider's Web close up shop. Paul appeared on two episodes of the podcast, Season 1’s ...
04/01/2023

Very sad to see our friends at The Spider's Web close up shop. Paul appeared on two episodes of the podcast, Season 1’s “Comic Shop Business School” and Season 3’s spotlight on TSW. And, of course, the shop was featured prominently in My Comic Shop Country. On a personal note, I always felt a special connection to TSW, given that Paul was one of our favorite customers at AR before opening his own store. Plus, back during the DC Rebirth era, I briefly had a pull list at TSW and enjoyed my time there. To Paul, Andrew, & co., thanks for a great ride and for the opportunity to tell your shop’s story. No flat squirrels here.

Greetings Web-Slingers!
•
With a heavy heart and sadness,
This announcement is hard for me to say……….
It was the best of times and after much contemplation, I have decided to close The Spiders Web this week. And there are a lot of factors that have made me move to this decision, which some of you may already know some of the reasons!
•
It has literally been a great ten years but it's time to move on to something else in which I can engage a new passion in life.
•
I would like to THANK ALL OF YOU for your friendship, patronage and continued support throughout the years.
•
Thank you for the spectacular and funny debates on various topics we had in the store. MCU Universe was the best of topics…..lmao!
And especially, thank you for the great fun and memories! I have met many great people and made lots of cool friends!
•
I really appreciate it all!!!
And most importantly, thank you for being a friend!
•
p.s
New DC Comics have are in stock but Marvel and Independent comics have not been received.
I’ll be here until The end of the week.
•
Again, Thank you!
Paul
•

Address


Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Comic Shop History posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to My Comic Shop History:

Shortcuts

  • Address
  • Alerts
  • Contact The Business
  • Claim ownership or report listing
  • Want your business to be the top-listed Media Company?

Share

Secret Origin

When I was five years old, a routine trip to the local galleria with my parents proved seminal when we happened upon the now-defunct comic book store Heroes World. To advertise the headline-making “Death of Superman” storyline, the store staged its window display with a Superman action figure in a small box mimicking a coffin. That moment in front of Heroes World drew me into the world not only of comics, but also of comic shops.

Ten years later and one town over, I was making one of my weekly visits to Alternate Realities in Scarsdale, NY, when the owner asked the question that would ultimately set me on my path: “Hey, kid, how’s your alphabet?” He was offering me a part-time job alphabetizing back issues, but really, he was inviting me into a community. I unpacked shipments, stocked shelves, worked the register, and did so much more over the following years. More importantly, I became part of a second family comprised of staff and customers alike as we bonded over our shared passion in that cluttered, but warm, store. Lively conversations, weekly dinners, and movie outings became part of my routine at a time when I did not have other people in my life who shared my hobby.

The Alternate Realities community was the subject of my first movie, My Comic Shop DocumentARy, which screened at film festivals across the country and garnered press in multiple media outlets, including The New York Times. When the store eventually closed in 2015, I chronicled its final days on my podcast, My Comic Shop History. That series continued beyond its original mission and is currently in its sixth year.

Then, I embarked on a quest to see if what I found at my shop also existed at others. The end result is My Comic Shop Country, which explores comic book stores across America and the different types of places they represent: they are clubhouses, time capsules, gathering places, and destinations. They are—individually and collectively—a community. At a time where face-to-face interactions, let alone meaningful ones, are increasingly rare, comic shops are struggling but enduring by remaining part of people’s routines.