30/06/2024
We talk a lot about subjects that should be taught in schools, like finance and civics, and there’s great merit to that. I’ll give you another: debate. Maybe add public speaking to this, but debate is important, because it forces you to look at all sides of an argument, and more than that, the “why” of an argument. This should be taught in every grade from an early age, and it should be both an independent class, and integrated into other classes. You read a book in English class, now debate one of the topics. You read about some historical event, now debate it. Debate the implications of scientific advances. Debate which sports team is better, or which Star Wars movie, or what should or shouldn’t have happened with a given character. Whatever. Argue it. Now, argue the opposite side. You identify as a Republican, now argue the Democrat side. You believe in God, now argue for atheism. Learn to educate yourself on an issue, and learn the greatest weaknesses in the argument, and learn to think and articulate and see it from multiple perspectives. Learn to lose. Learn that you’re often wrong. Learn humility! Learn that even when you win it’s almost never absolute, and that even the most seemingly obvious positions require nuance. Learn standards of proof. Learn that even the smartest person hardly knows anything, and that other people have valuable things to contribute, and are valuable themselves. Above all, just learn! And no, I say this not just because we have arrived finally at a terminal point, where we have these two ridiculous, clumsy buffoons running for president who can’t even speak in complete sentences or form coherent thoughts; and not just because we live in a deliberately diverse, pluralistic society which requires reconciliation of competing ideas and values (though that’s important); but because debate forces thinking, and to think is to learn, and when we stop learning we surrender to ignorance.