31/07/2022
That sounds like a pretty low bar, but in all honesty, it’s all I set out to do when I became a mum of two kids.
I had no lofty goal. I had no illusion that my kids would be BFFs. I guess you could say that I had realistic expectations. I reckoned that they each would have:
- Their own unique personality
- Their own preferences
- Their own set of friends.
Hence, from the get-go, I had no fantasy about them becoming “perfect siblings”. I just thought, “oh boy, this thing would be a success if they don’t hate each other!”
😅😅
With that goal in mind, I navigated sibling dynamics quite differently from the traditional norm.
What is the norm? I saw parents around me placing what I would call ‘traditional expectations’ on the older child.
Typically, I overhear parents telling the older / oldest child:
- “You are the older sister, so you have to give in to the younger one” (Hello, was it her fault that she was the first to be born? If not, why penalize her for something she could not control?)
- “You must set a good example for your siblings, because you are older” (Faulty logic and honestly, just a very lousy motivator for good behaviour. In short, it doesn’t work!)
- “No, you can’t do that. If I allow you to do that, the younger ones will want to follow you.”
Whenever I overhear such exchanges, my immediate thought would be, “Woah… that’s the fastest way to make your older child resent his/her siblings!”
True enough, over time, I often saw the dynamics play out to their logical conclusion:
- Resentment: The older child hates being held ‘responsible’ for the shenanigans of the younger ones
- Entitlement: Because she ‘suffered’ for being the older one, she feels entitled to throw her weight around: “You all better listen to me okay, because I am older than you”
- Threats & Emotional Blackmail: Not only did this faulty logic not work, it also gives the younger ones a trump card to wield around, such as: “You must give in to us, because you are Jie Jie… If not, we will complain to Mummy / Daddy that you didn’t give way to us.”
🤨🤨
Can you see how parents unwittingly weaponise the birth order, and unknowingly create resentment between siblings?
Imagine being told by your manager at work: “Sorry ah, you will get paid less than So-and-so, even though your work and work attitude are better, because he/she happens to be 4 years older than you.”
Would you be happy?
If not, why do we think our children would be happy to accept such flawed and faulty logic?
How patently unfair! We would never accept that being done to us, so why in the world do we impose that on our kids?
🤔 🤔 🤔
So if I spurned the traditional approach, what then did I do instead? I would sum up our approach this way:
1. In our household, age is neither an advantage or disadvantage.
- I don’t expect more of my older child simply “because you are Jie Jie (older sister)”.
- In the same vein, I don’t expect less from my younger child just because she is younger (within age appropriate limits, of course).
- This places them on equal footing, in that, right is right and wrong is wrong, regardless of birth order. (Because, why would you penalize someone simply for being the first to be born?)
2. Choices — not age and birth order — determine our responses to our children’s behaviour.
- We compliment or correct based on their actions and choices.
- That means saying “Could you help me fold the laundry please?”, rather than “You have to help me fold the laundry because you are older.”
🔫🔫🔫
The problem with weaponizing age and birth order is that you end up creating resentment which, left unchecked, will grow into full-blown bitterness.
Bitterness is like that insidious, never-say-die seedling that sprouts up from the cracks in the pavement.
If given even the smallest entry point into the sibling relationship, bitterness takes root, grows, and ends up ruining the relationship between siblings.
**
Caveat: Now if the ‘traditional’ approach has worked for your family thus far, good on you!
But if you are grappling with strained sibling relationships, and would like a parent coach like me to coach you from the sidelines, helping you improve your parenting game — message me and let’s set up that coaching call ☎️