18/04/2021
From a Taller Tower||Seamus McGraw
â˘
â˘
[thank you to for sending a copy for review]
A journalist examines the history of mass shootings in America. An attempt to explain how these things happen and how complex it all is.
â˘
â˘
I had mixed feelings about this book. I wanted to love it because Iâd hoped it would shed light on the types of mass shootings that have become part of American life. The subtitle led me to believe thatâs where we would go. That Iâd have more clarity on who commits these crimes and why, and what weâve seen that evolution to be since the 1960âs. Instead McGraw takes a few mass shootings and profiles the crime trying to extrapolate a point, like the harmfulness of calling these shooters âevilâ. The book is less direct than Iâd hoped.
â˘
â˘
I think more than anything the book falls short because it lacks thesis or direction. Each section could easily be an essay, and theyâre mostly interesting, but together the book doesnât say much, except maybe America is totally fu**ed. Which does seem to hold water given the last few weeks of mass shooting after mass shooting. In a book of this nature less graphic chronicling of mass murder and more analytic understanding wouldâve been appreciated. The book lacks a lot of the interesting things Iâve read around race, gender, religion, and class when it comes to these crimes.
â˘
â˘
Seamus McGraw has a strong voice and this book is easy to follow. I was never bored and I was mostly interested. Though at times he leans into rhetoric devices that play games around what ifâs and get dangerously close to advocating for the devil. I didnât find any of that helpful.
â˘
â˘
Iâm taking recommendations for books about mass shootings, so please share yours in the comments.
â˘
â˘
Iâm glad I read this book, I did learn things. I just hoped it would have done more to push the conversation around these types of public acts of terror and violence. As we seem to so desperately need to make sense of this.
â˘
â˘