25/12/2024
A well written review for Vetrimaaran's Viduthalai 2,which is currently running successfully in theaters.
What is the cost of freedom? and who pays for it?
Viduthalai Part 1 was a gripping and emotionally charged narrative that took us along a immersive journey with Kumaresan, a man navigating the harsh realities of systemic injustice. It ended on a high note with the capture of Vaathiyaar, leaving a cascade of questions: Who is Vaathiyaar? What shaped him? And what sinister political manipulations surround him?
Part 2 rightfully delves deep into these questions but shifts its focus outward. It unpacks the layers surrounding Vaathiyaar, exploring the complex intersections of power, oppression, and resistance.Is it a right way to handle a story? Probably not but I believe Vetrimaran knows better and he took the conscious decision to make it more than just a film but a chance to put out all the political questions within him that seek some kind of release, all of the questions raised stay true to the title and purpose of the film, what is the cost of freedom? and who pays?
The film serves as a powerful exposé, shedding light on the brutal political maneuvers employed against marginalized communities not too long ago. Through its sprawling 2.45-hour runtime, it evolves into a cinematic manifesto, an unflinching reflection on the sacrifices made by unsung leaders to secure the freedoms we often take for granted today. Vetrimaran doesn’t shy away from showing the cold calculations of those in power with actual refrences to real events. By doing so, the film challenges its audience to confront these uncomfortable truths and question the systems that perpetuate such injustices.
However, in its earnest attempt to cram in layers of political commentary, historical context, and moral introspection, Part 2 sometimes stumbles when it comes to nuance. Unlike the emotional depth of Part 1, this installment leans heavily on exposition, with overlapping voiceovers and dialogues often feeling like a lecture rather than a natural progression of the story. The heavy-handedness occasionally detracts from the emotional connection, making it feel more like an educational piece than an organic continuation of the narrative which is unusual for Vetrimaaran film. Though this diminishes the subtlety and emotional depth that defined the first part the film occasionally redeems itself through authentic, intimate moments that punctuate the narrative.
On the other hand, the action sequences and technical ex*****on are raw and grounded, and the backdrop of the forest adds a layer of unease that mirrors the struggles of its characters, the climactic sequences, particularly, are a testament to the technical brilliance of the team, creating an experience that is both gripping and emotionally arresting. Perhaps the film’s biggest surprise was Ilayaraja’s stunning background score - a triumphant return to form in BGM compositions, injecting scenes with a raw intensity.
Despite the shortcomings, the film’s intent and relevance cannot be overstated, for a generation that largely remains detached from political discourse, Viduthalai serves as a need of the moment wake-up call. While it may not have the emotional pull of its predecessor, it compensates with its socio political relevance, making it a significant piece of work that demands attention.
By the end it becomes evident that the film was not just about Vaathiyaar or Kumaresan but about the larger idea of resistance against oppression. It forces us to reckon with the stories of unsung heroes and the systems that tried to silence them. Though flawed in its ex*****on, the film remains a vital conversation starter about justice, sacrifice, and the cost of freedom.
We are a small production team working on and creating short films of a variety of genres. Beginners
