06/01/2022
POKÉMON BRILLIANT DIAMOND & SHINING PEARL (NINTENDO SWITCH) REVIEW:
The aim of the game is to be the best Pokemon trainer out there from ground up with nothing but a starter Pokemon. My choice was Chimchar - a fire type. There's not many of those in the game. The others are Turtwig, the grass type, and Piplup the water type. It's just a matter of what your preference is in gameplay. What type of elements you use to battle the gym leaders in each town, before reaching stardom and claiming your legendary Pokemon. The difference between the two games is the exclusive Pokemon you get, as well as the legendaries.
A GRAPHICALLY BAD REMAKE:
These games are remakes of the classics on the DS and have finally come to the Nintendo Switch. Although fans may be pleased to relive and rekindle their old times from back in 2006, newer gamers might be somewhat shocked and disappointed in the art style with its bland textures, strangely though, there are some excellent reflections that make no sense in this Frankenstein stitch up of a game. Compared to the originals, I myself preferred the orignal direction on the DS due to the newer graphics being abysmal under the direction of Gamefreak. There are all kinds of glitches with the framerate dropping under 30fps, to flickering and glitches. The day and night cycle switches a bit too instantly too, creating a jarring sensation of confusion. Another stupid thing is the overuse of exaggerated blooming - I really wish I could turn that off.
WEIRD ART STYLE MIX IS STRANGE:
A main concern for me was the chibi art style in the overworld where you run freely, but the NPCs still walk in a grid formation, and the battle scenes consisting of a Sword/Shield artstyle, which throws me off. The battle scenes do have nice backgrounds, but after playing Sword/Shield, I miss the bells and whistles, especially the Gigantimax abilities.
AUDIO IS GOOD, BUT HAS PROBLEMS:
The support studio who made the conversion of this game is ILCA Inc, known for assisting in the development of Yakuza 0, Nier Replicant, Code Vein, Metal Gear Rising and more.
THE PREVIOUS SWITCH GAMES ARE WAY SUPERIOR:
The sad news is that the game looks worse than Pokemon Let's Go Pikachu/Eevee and Pokemon Sword/Shield. There's even indie games that look better too. This breaks the immersion of what is a great game underneath, with one of the best maps ever to appear in a Pokemon game. There's all kinds of areas, like grasslands, deserts, frozen tundras, cities, small villages, beaches, caves and more.
QUALITY OF LIFE IMPROVEMENTS:
With quality of life improvements lifted from Sword/Shield, this game does benefit from modern gameplay in some ways, like the simultaneous levelling up of your party. They have also integrated the Pokétch watch in the top right corner using the R button. With this device you can perform special abilities to access the game's hidden paths and areas.
HIDDEN AREAS:
Speaking of hidden areas, there's a place called the Grand Underground where you can find rare Pokemon, kind of like in the Wild Area of Sword/Shield. There are also treasures to be found where you mine the walls before they cave in, after which you claim whatever b***y you've dug up. These areas are varied and are some of where the most fun is had.
CATCHY REMASTERED AUDIO:
The audio has been remastered and offers some of the most catchy music in the franchise yet, however it is lacking in surround sound. My preference is again with Pokemon Let's Go Pikachu/Eevee, which is a surround sound audio masterpiece, offering remixes that are serene to listen to during gameplay. Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl's audio does suffer from glitches from time to time to and can be a bit grating at points with repetition.
GAMEPLAY IS FUN, BUT CAN BE FRUSTRATING:
With gameplay, you do get used the shortcomings and technical issues. Although there are some modern improvements to the playability, there's still some awkward repetitive grinding moments that are unwelcome. I was at one section and every two steps I took, I got into battles with invisible enemies like the old days or RPGs. There was even a point where I finished one battle and went into another one immediately after. I got so frustrated that I wanted to rage quit and never turn the game on again. This game really needed the Pokemon Let's Go Pikachu/Eevee level of modernisation to really shine. Right now its neither brilliant or shining and quite the opposite. Also where's the HD Rumble?
SOME MEMORABLE MOMENTS:
It's not all bad news though.. there are some really interesting pokemon to catch, embedded in a great storyline. I love the transportation too, particularly with how I was awarded a bicycle with the colour of my choice. This was rather personal and actually felt like an exciting moment of my childhood. The attention to detail is phenomenal with a gear system affecting how you traverse terrain - absolute genius. There's tons to unlock and explore in the world, with loads of surprises around every corner.
SUMMARY:
I can't really recommend this game, other than to fans of the franchise who wish to relive their nostalgia. It could have been something great, but falls short in many ways and is definitely not worth the full game price of £49.99. That's a total rip-off if you ask me. This game should have been a digital download for £19.99 in its current form. You're best off buying Pokemon Sword/Shield which is my favourite of the series so far, or wait for Pokemon Legends Arceus.
SCORE: 3/5