15/12/2023
Geronimo’s Relationship with Naiche
(Geronimo and Naiche Resting by the Train Carrying Their Band East 1886. Photograph courtesy National Archives)
This post, part of a series about the Chiricahua and Geronimo prisoner of war years and events leading up to them summarizes what happened to the Chiricahua Apaches after Geronimo surrendered to General Miles, September 4, 1886, under terms that were false. The full story of Geronimo’s years as a prisoner of war can found in the 2019 book: Geronimo, Prisoner of Lies, Twenty-Three Years as a Prisoner of War by W. Michael Farmer. A novel, The Odyssey of Geronimo is a novel of Geronimo’s years in captivity told through his eyes that puts meat and sinew on the bones of the documented and Apache oral history told in Prisoner of Lies. The Odyssey of Geronimo will be released in mid-May 2020 by Five Star.
Cochise had two sons: Taza and Naiche. Cochise groomed Taza, the elder son, to assume the leadership of the Chokonen Chiricahuas even though being the chief of the tribe was not normally inherited. Cochise died in 1874 and Taza became chief of the Chokonens on the reservation his father had agreed to with General (One Arm) Howard in 1872 providing Tom Jeffords was his agent. Most of the tribe thought Taza would be a wise and good chief. However, about twelve warriors led by Skinya and his brother Poinsenay believed the older more experienced warrior Skinya should be chief and established their own camp in the mountains away from where most of the band lived. The argument over who should be chief came to a head on 4 June 1876 when there was a gunfight between Taza’s and Skinya’s groups. During the fight, Naiche shot Skinya in the head and killed him, Taza wounded Poinsenay, and six others were killed. That ended the disagreement over who should be chief.
The same day as the gunfight, John Clum, agent at San Carlos, appeared with cavalry backup to talk Taza and Naiche into leaving Cochise’s reservation and moving their people to San Carlos. The move was part of Washington bureaucracy’s poorly conceived policy of reservation consolidation. Taza and Naiche, remembering their father’s dying wish to avoid fighting with the White Eyes if at all possible, agree to move their people to San Carlos. Tom Jeffords told Clum that Geronimo, Juh, and Nolgee had a band living on another part of the reservation and were included in General Howard’s original agreement with Cochise. Geronimo and Juh met with Clum four days later and said they would move too, but they had to go back and get their people. Clum agreed but sent a couple of his scouts to shadow them back to their village. The scouts returned to tell Clum that Geronimo and the others had taken their families and disappeared across the border. It was the first time Geronimo had broken out of a reservation.
Clum was so full of himself for all his successful reservations consolidations that he decided to take at trip back east in September of 1876 to show off twenty of the Apaches then at San Carlos including chiefs Taza and Eskiminzin. (Clum actually wanted an excuse to travel back east to marry a lady in Ohio to whom he was engaged and he put on the Indian show as a way to pay travel expenses). The tour ended in Washington and had been a big success. However, while in Washington, Taza caught pneumonia and died. (Some Apaches believed Clum poisoned Taza, but that was clearly not the case. In fact, Clum gave Taza such a grand funeral he had to borrow money for train tickets to get back to the reservation).
The Chiricahuas decided that Naiche, then nineteen years old, and who liked women, fighting, drinking, and Indian dancing should be chief. He was too young to be a leader and even in his mature years, as a fine warrior, he lacked the temperament to exercise authority. In 1877 Clum captured Geronimo (the only time Geronimo didn’t voluntarily surrender) at Victorio’s Warm Springs Apache camp on the Ojo Caliente reservation in New Mexico. While there, Clum, following orders from Washington, talked Victorio into bringing his people to San Carlos, again as part of the consolidation policy. Returning to San Carlos with Victorio and Geronimo and five to seven (depending on who you believe) of his leading warriors in shackles, Clum put the Geronimo and his war leaders in the guardhouse and told the sheriff in Tucson to come collect Geronimo for civil prosecution for murder and horse theft, which meant certain hanging from a civil court. The sheriff never came; Clum in a bitter argument with the army over who controlled San Carlos, left in a huff; and, the new agent, Lyman Hart, seeing no reason to keep him if the sheriff hadn’t come, released Geronimo.
In early September 1877, after three months at San Carlos, Victorio outraged by Clum’s false claims about what a heaven-on-earth San Carlos was and seeing his People dying from smallpox and ill from the “shaking sickness” (malaria), starving and poorly clothed, broke out with Loco and 323 of their followers leaving only about 20 behind. Naiche and most of the Chiricahuas stayed on the reservation. Geronimo didn’t leave either, and Hart made him “captain” of the Warm Springs People who had stayed behind. Geronimo promised Hart he would not leave the reservation and would inform him of any talk from the others about a breakout. But, dissatisfaction with life on the reservation continued to grow and warriors began stealing and hiding guns and ammunition and their women laid aside food preparing for a breakout. It came on 4 April 1878 when Geronimo, Ponce, and other warriors left the reservation for Mexico. It was Geronimo’s first San Carlos breakout. Naiche continued to peacefully stay on the reservation with his People.
Believing civil authorities were about to arrest him, Victorio, who stayed mostly peaceful while trying to live on a reservation in New Mexico, left the Mescalero reservation in late August 1879. He roared across the southwest like a forest fire in dry tender burning and killing nearly everything in his path. Armies on both sides of the border were desperate to stop him. Geronimo and Juh, knowing they might be implicated in Victorio’s war and caught in the surround to wipe out Victorio, returned to San Carlos in late December 1879 or early January 1880. Ten months later, Victorio, out of ammunition, was wiped out at Tres Castillos in October 1880 by Mexican military led by Colonel Joaquin Terrazas. By contrast, Geronimo, Juh, and their followers had been living quietly on the reservation.
The following year in July 1881 Nana, Victorio’s segundo, his number two, with about fifteen Chihenne warriors and maybe twenty-five Mescaleros began a raid lasting about six weeks that covered up to seventy miles in a day, killed anyone in his path (about fifty), and stole over two hundred head of horses and mules. The army sent eight companies of cavalry, eight companies of infantry, and two companies of scouts after him, but he disappeared south into the Sierra Madre, and the chase was abandoned. Geronimo and Juh and their people on the reservation were not directly affected by Nana’s raid, but the panic it instilled in government officials caused them to overreact to perceived threats that were not threats at all. The result drove once peaceable Apaches off the reservation and into camps in the Sierra Madre in Mexico where they believed they were safe from blue coat attack. On 30 September 1881, the peaceable Naiche and most of his Chiricahua warriors and their families joined Geronimo and Juh with of their seventy-four warriors and headed south. This was the first known incident where chief Naiche, then about twenty-four, followed Geronimo’s lead off the reservation.
During the nearly two years of peace after Geronimo and the other Chiricahuas returned to the reservation in early 1880, Naiche had made him his medicine man (Geronimo claimed supernatural powers, Naiche did not) and gave him his war leader responsibilities. As Daklugie related to Eve Ball years later, Geronimo had said when they met at Fort Pickens after their surrenders in 1886, “. . . I was never elected to chieftainship, I had this thing also (ed. qualities of leadership), and men knew it. Had Naiche been older, experienced in warfare and a Medicine Man as I was, he would never have depended upon me to exercise many of his prerogatives. But he was not. And he was wise enough to know that the life of his people depended upon someone who could do these things. And I, rather, rather than see my race perish from Mother Earth, cared little who was chief so long as I could direct the fighting and preserve even a few of our people. . .”
In the years that followed Naiche was content to let Geronimo take the lead in fighting and negotiating with the White Eyes. Naiche remained in the background during the 1883 surrender and the 1885 breakout and 1886 surrender. However, there are a number of examples where Naiche exercised his authority as chief over Geronimo. For example when Geronimo ordered warriors to kill a child after a sheep camp had been taken in early 1882, Naiche ordered the child to be let go. After Martine and Kayitah, scouts for Lieutenant Gatewood came to Geronimo’s camp above the big turn south by the Bavispe River and convinced Geronimo and the warriors to speak with Gatewood about surrender to General Miles, Naiche made a point of telling Martine and Kayitah to tell Gatewood that he had Naiche’s word that he would not be harmed if he came to the camp. After Naiche became a Christian, he encouraged Geronimo to become a Christian too, was delighted when he did, and badly disappointed when Geronimo slipped back into his old ways of hard drinking (when he could get the whiskey) and gambling on everything from horse racing to monte card games. However, when Geronimo held a big feast to celebrate his daughter Eva’s coming of age ceremony, Naiche led the singing while Geronimo led the dancing, and Naiche provided a nice spot of ground where the ceremony was held. When Naiche’s children were sick, Geronimo used his power as a Medicine man to help cure them. More than one who knew them said that they were friendly, but not friends.
After Geronimo died from pneumonia Naiche spoke graveside at his service. He said Geronimo had been a brave and skillful war leader, but had loyally adhered to the peace he made at the surrender. However, Geronimo had refused to accept Christianity, and was thus an utter failure in the chief thing in life. Naiche closed by urging the assembled people to profit by Geronimo’s example.
Next Week: Geronimo Meets the Son He Didn’t Know He Had
Most of the information for this post is from Geronimo by Angie Debo, Indeh by Eve Ball, Nora Henn, and Lynda Sánchez, and Apache