17/11/2023
Rosaria Butterfield's recent critique of Cru, Revoice, and Dr. Preston Sprinkle came as a surprise. Her journey and writings have deeply influenced me, offering both inspiration and challenges. The situation, which I considered discussing on my podcast Faith Over Breakfast with Pastor Andy Littleton of Mission Church, underscores a significant issue in the Christian community. Although Andy wasn't enthusiastic about this topic, it's important to grasp the essence of the matter. Butterfield, in a speech at Liberty University, accused these organizations, known for supporting those wrestling with faith and sexuality within the LGBTQ community, of compromising their foundational principles. While I'm not revealing my personal viewpoint, I am concerned about what appears to be a lack of consideration for fellow believers who share her views on marriage and sexuality.
In my role as a pastor, I often see similar mindsets — Christians focused on correcting others in areas like politics and theology. We find it challenging to truly live out love, forgiveness, and gentleness. Butterfield is certainly entitled to her concerns about public positions, particularly on such a sensitive topic as sexuality. Yet, her direct confrontation, especially with Dr. Sprinkle, seems at odds with our Christian duty to honor and gently guide one another towards Christ-like actions.
Reflecting on Butterfield's approach, I see similarities in my own actions, which might contribute to the issue. In Christianity, understanding the impact of our actions on our community and places of worship is crucial. We encounter a wide range of disagreements, spanning politics, gender roles, eschatology, and even our understanding of personal interactions and friendship.
Community life is a cornerstone of Christian practice. When addressing issues with others, it's advisable to follow Paul's example in his approach to Peter — engaging directly in a personal setting. This aligns with the guidance in Galatians 6:1, which says, "Brothers and sisters, if someone is caught in a sin, you who live by the Spirit should restore that person gently. But watch yourselves, or you also may be tempted.(NIV)" Fostering division aligns with the adversary's goals, urging us to choose sides, be it with Team Rosaria or Team Preston. My respect for both Preston and Rosaria remains, as I have learned much from them. As public figures, they are positioned to demonstrate maintaining care and respect within community, even amidst differing viewpoints. This biblical principle of gentle restoration and self-awareness in our interactions is a valuable guide in navigating our community's diverse perspectives.
