08/06/2024
Sorry not sorry....this matters. Amoral AI-pushing tech corporations and their shareholders want to profit from using everything that comes from your mind and imagination - and your work of creating it - without any credit or compensation, legally depriving you - if they can get their way with courts and lawmakers - of your own natural rights of authorship.
If you haven't studied intellectual property law as it relates to the arts and entertainment, you should - because whether you're a professional, amateur, or hobbyist, tech corporations want it to become legal and normalized for all your online-accessible creative work to be utilized by others in open competition against you.
Here's where it gets a little technical - but bear with me:
Intentional competition within the same genre would be a pretty decisive red flag when it comes to proving musical copyright infringement, and publically-released genAI is based upon the full expectation of the direct competition (for both attention and financial gain) of AI-generated output against the finished works that are exploited to composite it - and against their creators' ability to profit from the further continuance of their own artistic work, whether independently or via formal employment.
This is not a matter of "democratizing" art. Being an artist is already accessible - all you have to do is do art, and do it yourself. This is the opposite of empowering individual artists. It is one more face of neoliberalism trying to give more "freedom" to already-existing capital to exploit every naturally-existing resource in the world. There's a lot of investment money riding on this. And every usage of a generative-AI program builds into the investor-desired impression that this is what consumers want and accept.
There is no ethical usage of genAI. It's environmentally wasteful and it's based in plagiarism. It is made to steal from all of us, and if you think that you are using it as a tool, it is using YOU as an economic tool against yourself and everyone else who isn't already safely established as wealthy and successful. It's a fraud, and it's an overhyped bubble that's going to burst.
We need a tipping-point weight of solidarity across the board, whatever anyone's job, vocation(s), or discipline(s) or medium(s) used for expression. Writing is art, music is art, translation is art, acting is art, modeling is art, crocheting is art, cake decorating is art....whatever you bring forth that comes from your own instincts and efforts is art. Nothing AI-generated is art, and it has no artist either. Only human-made works can be registered under U.S. copyright law. People who use generative AI don't have legal rights of authorship over what comes out of it - whatever they might claim or believe by the way they act.
Those people can be extremely smug and taunting. They think they're riding this wave to success over everyone else. But they're cheating themselves of everything that they could be, as well as worsening the state of the world.
This isn't a frivolous request, nor is the concern exaggerated. If we want to force this world to improve for real, it's crucially important now to take a firm stand for truth and integrity, and to refuse absolutely and explicitly to grease the wheels of this AI bus - because the tech-corporatist intention is for all of us to get thrown under it.
"Artists Make Lousy Slaves" - as the poster says. Corporatists have seen a way to get rid of the costly inconvenience of having to deal with conscious and actively-practicing human artists at all....as long as they can get everyone else who doesn't understand or care about taking art seriously to play along with their shiny new thieving toys.