17/11/2024
https://www.wruu.org/broadcasts/54592
I threw a book against the wall this week.
Let me be more specific. It didn’t actually hit the wall, but the door of the closet in my office. It bounced once and landed beside the previously sleeping dog. The dog’s head je**ed up, first looking at the book and then at me. That look reminded me of those glares that my father gave me when I was a child, after I’d committed some childhood breach of commonly accepted behavior. Then I retrieved the book and the dog went back to sleep.
I have lived through exciting and significant times, and books about them appear with disturbing frequency. The frequency is disturbing because they construct narratives about events that I witnessed, narratives that bear little relationship to the things I experienced. Their publishers allege that they are non-fiction, but a jury of their peers might decide otherwise.
Sometimes they are written by others who lived through the same period, but more often, the writers hadn’t quite outgrown wetting diapers when the event occurred, if they were that developed. The books string together unrelated events in a specific time period, using logic that is currently fashionable, to prove some point dearly beloved of the author. They usually get their facts wrong, emphasize the negligible, and reach general conclusions that have no relationship to the era or the events. The book was one of those.
Why read those things if they are so disturbing? It’s something like social media. It’s full of observations and information that don’t mean anything, with a fair proportion being dead wrong. But occasionally, somebody posts something that is both meaningful and accurate, a pearl that might justify the mountain of oyster shells I had to go through to find it.
Dave Maraniss has written quite a few of those. Maraniss is Pulitzer-winning reporter and editors who has written a number of books about sports or political personalities – his books on Jim Thorpe, Vince Lombardi, and Roberto Clemente are fascinating portraits. But his book on Detroit is a fine example of that kind of explanation.
Maraniss was born and grew up in Detroit. His love for the city of his youth shines through every page. Titled Once in a Great City, it describes the Detroit of the 60’s, when he was old enough to understand the dynamics and while the city still boomed. The Detroit of the 60’s was a vital part of the country. American-made autos still ruled the road. Detroit’s mayor, Jerome Cavanaugh, had influence well beyond city boundaries, and Motown became an influential source of American music. Not that long before, Charles Wilson had declared “what was good for our country was good for General Motors, and vice versa.” The claim was more persuasive when applied to Detroit in general.
The rise of Motown has always attracted attention. Why would Detroit be a major source of music? It didn’t have the heritage of Nashville or New Orleans or Chicago, nor the critical mass of Los Angeles or New York. Motown was well-run and collected a remarkably brilliant set of acts, but how did it come to be in Detroit?
Maraniss tells us in a short paragraph:
First, because of the auto plants and related industries, most Detroiters had steady salaries and families enjoyed a measure of disposable income they could use to listen to music in clubs and at home. Second, the economic geography of the city meant that the vast majority of residents lived in single-family houses, not high-rise apartments, making it easier to deliver pianos and find room for them. And third, Detroit had the egalitarian advantage of a remarkable piano enterprise, the Grinnell Brothers Music House.”
The Grinnell Brothers made piano ownership easy and affordable, which is why they get special mention.
None of that fully explains the brilliance of the Motown performers and operation, of course. That shine depended on the talent and dedication of those people, many of whom made great and little-known contributions besides performance. But the economic background that Maraniss cites provided a platform from which that brilliance could develop and shine.
Since the mid-19th Century, most analysts of human behavior have pointed to economics as the basis for a culture. Economics, that measure of disposable income that Maraniss writes about, caused music, but it also causes art and literature. It also causes scientific discovery, medical advances, and the promotion of just and equitable societies. The things that make life worth living can be constructed on that same economic platform.
Almost everyone understands the economic basis, because almost everyone has a very limited amount of that disposable income, and some have none at all. Threats to the economic basis, real or imagined, cause the most violent societal reactions.
Nothing proves the point like the lack of that income. Sixty years on from the events Maraniss records, the advantages of Detroit have withered away, starting with the automobile industry. Detroit’s experience has been duplicated by many other places in the industrial Midwest, what we commonly refer to as the Rust Belt.
The events in the book run from autumn 1962 to spring 1964, and they include difficult decisions and dangerous situations as well as a sense of the positive characteristics of that time. Maraniss sees the seeds of the current problems in the details of that past time – likely, part of the rationale for writing the book may be to understand that progression.
That’s useful, even for non-historians. The sixty years since those events have seen a multiplication of problems for Detroit – they didn’t happen overnight. The restoration of Detroit’s vitality will require understanding how it happened. And how it happened must include economic factors, social factors, political factors and a wealth of others. There are no simple solutions, because the problems are not simple.
But all of those factors are built on economic revival. Without it, talent remains undeveloped, society becomes more confrontational and less just, and the ability to maintain a population erodes. If the book provides a lesson in that, the lesson is applicable far beyond Detroit city limits. Those who ignore it do so at their own peril.
When the Moon Sings Share Tweet Email 4:39pm Rain Falls by David Helpling on Sleeping on the Edge of the World (Spotted Peccary) 5:01pm My Bells by Bill Evans Trio with Symphony Orchestra on Bill Evans Trio with Symphony Orchestra (Verve) 5:08pm Cinema Paradiso (Main Theme) by Charlie Haden/Pat M**h...