08/11/2022
ASHLAND — Nine more Amish people, including two women, pleaded no contest to violating Ohio’s new buggy law before a judge at Ashland Municipal Court on Tuesday.
Abraham Hershberger, David Mast, Mosie Shetler, Levi P. Gingerich, Enos Miller, Levi L. Gingerich, Lizzie L. Hershberger, Fannie E. Hershberger and Mahlon J. Swartzentruber each stood before Ashland Municipal Court Judge John Good without the representation of an attorney.
Each were charged separately with not having yellow flashing lights attached to their buggies, according to court records.
The “no contest” plead means the people waived their rights to a trial. Ashland Municipal Court Judge John Good found the people guilty and sentenced them to pay a fine of $50.
Mahlon J. Swartzentruber stands before Ashland Municipal Court Judge John Good on Tuesday, Nov. 8 for not having a yellow flashing light attached to his buggy.
Judge Good said he understands the argument. But he had a question for Mahlon J. Swartzentruber, who confirmed to Good on Tuesday that he is a leader within his community.
“Your folks have religious reservations about the law, you disagree with it. And you think it interferes with your religious freedom — and I understand that,” Good said. “So how does this end?”
He said the tickets are going to keep coming, because law enforcement is trying to keep motorists safe. But if the Amish refuse to pay the fine, he will be forced to do something about it, he said.
“I can’t just let people just say, ‘I’m not going to pay my tickets.’ Because why should anybody? Why should any person in this room pay their fines if I let the Amish get away with not paying their fines? I wouldn’t be doing my job,” Good said.
The judge said he doesn’t want to put the Amish people in jail for not paying their fines.
“But it might get to that point, where I have to do that. And that’s not going to be a happy day for me,” he said.
Swartzentruber, like Good, is caught between a rock and a hard place.
“We know the law and we try to live in peace with everyone. And we pay our taxes,” Swartzentruber said, adding that he and his family are also trying to live in peace with the church, along with its rules and traditions.
Before being fined $50, Swartzentruber said there is consideration among him and his community for appealing the charges so that the conflict can be resolved in a higher court.
Enos Miller, however, received a fine of $50 for the first offense and $100 for the second offense. Miller received two tickets for the same offense one day apart.
Judge Good said the max sentence for this misdemeanor is a fine of $150, plus court costs.
Tuesday’s hearings brought the tally of Amish people charged under the new law in Ashland County to 25.
The Ashland County Sheriff’s Office began enforcing the new law that went into effect Aug. 31 in October. It requires Amish buggies and other animal-drawn vehicles to display a yellow flashing light while driving on public streets.
Since they have been charged, some of the Amish have argued through written letters that having yellow flashing lights would mean compromising their faith and trust in God. Many have refused to pay the fines associated with the misdemeanor charges.
Link to article
https://www.ashlandsource.com/news/9-more-amish-from-ashland-county-plead-no-contest-to-state-buggy-law-violations/article_b1f1eeb0-5f91-11ed-96e2-87d27d532ef4.html