18/08/2023
How impartial are City Council Officers?
Around 80% of the services delivered by the Council would remain largely unchanged regardless of political changes at election time. Bins will be collected (with varying reliability), grass will be cut (with varying frequency) but by and large these core services continue without much issue. The remaining 20% is where politics intervenes with the hope of creating enough change and associated recognition that the electorate repay their gratitude at the ballot box.
Up until recently Derby held elections by thirds (elections every year with a third of Councillors up for election), however in May this changed to all out elections that now occur every four years with all Council seats on offer. This change was enacted to bring about stability, preventing a change of control of the council every year and of course save money.
Despite political changes the constant over the years has been the Council Officers of varying levels within the authority, these mainly unseen figures are guiding/informing/controlling (delete as necessary) all of the key functions of the council and the larger strategic decisions with regards contracts, infrastructure projects and capital investment projects.
All of these Officer roles are politically restricted (no political affiliation allowed) and should remain impartial whatever the political party colour in charge. But is this a realistic or even practical requirement? With a very senior Officer within the Council being quoted as saying “What we need is a Labour Government” in relation to local authority settlement in addition to being a self-confessed card-carrying member of the Labour Party in their younger years, how can this be impartiality? It should also be noted that the same Officer has openly declared that “Derby will have to have a clean air zone” something that the Labour Group in Derby has hinted at historically and has stated that Low Traffic Neighbourhoods will indeed be part of their plans now that they are in control of Derby City Council.
To take this issue further, does this then mean that a party with socialist values would be better received by such an intrinsic figure within the council and therefore receive a better service than that of a party that was not of their persuasion?
Therefore, would an Officer cohort with Labour leaning values be more inclined to deliver on manifesto commitments from a Labour Group and equally be obstructive and unhelpful to that of any other party?
Derby City Council has seen many, significant changes and projects over the years. The introduction of Westfield (now Derbion) to the city, the Derby Arena, Duckworth Square development, the Assembly Rooms and of course the Sinfin Waste plant. All have been overseen by differing political parties but all have always and continue to have so called impartial Officer involvement. How impartial, that’s clearly up for debate….