24/08/2022
“My dream is to fly on an airplane.” Neilesh Bose and Andrea Wright discuss the dreams and realities of Indian Gulf migrants and how this contributes to the reshaping of global capitalism. We also include an excerpt, "The Rig and the Temple" from Wright's recent book for our readers.
---
"Over the course of my research, many of the Indian workers I interviewed in the Gulf associated Hindu nationalism with modernity and development. In the book, I wanted to depict the variety of ways migrants engaged with Hindu nationalism in order to draw attention to and reframe the meanings of state and nation. In particular, I was interested in showing how migrants position themselves as part of India’s development and how they critically insert themselves as part of the national body.
For example, Mohammed, a Muslim from northern India, worked at the rig construction project. As he described the importance of his work building oil infrastructure, he told me it helped him be a good son by allowing him to send money to his father. But the meaning he gave his work at this project extended past fulfilling his familial obligations to also reflecting a way he contributed to the future of India. Mohammed explicitly connected his work to the process of “making India modern” and described his migration as a way to help both his country and his community progress economically and ideologically.
Mohammed was not the only person who situated work on Gulf oil projects as part of India’s modernization. Both prospective migrants and current migrants tell me, with sincerity and excitement, that they work, or want to work, in the Gulf to “make India modern.” When men like Mohammed tell me this, I usually inquire as to what “modern” means, as the word seems, to me, to be amorphous and fleeting.
In their answers, Indian migrants describe modernity and development as improvements to infrastructure, which includes airplanes, electricity, and clean running water. They also describe it as the increased consumption of commodities.
In addition, workers from groups that face structural inequalities, such as Muslims, Adivasis (indigenous Indians), and Dalits, tell me their work in the Gulf contributes to modernity because it helps their community “stop being backward” or improves their community’s socioeconomic status.
However, “making India modern” is not limited to material consumption and infrastructure; it implies more difficult-to-articulate dreams, including freedom; living in the city; doing what you want; and love matches as opposed to arranged marriages."
Editor’s Note: In the following essay, Neilesh Bose presents an overview of the recently published book, Between Dreams and Ghosts: Indian Migration and Middle Eastern Oil (2021) by Andrea Wr…