09/02/2021
Science thinking lesson time!
The recent headlines about the AZ-Oxford vaccine in South Africa being virtually powerless against the B.1.351 variant require some deeper thought. The first reaction of the media is to claim that the variants are smarter than the vaccines. Let's see why that's probably not true.
A larger study conducted by Johnson & Johnson recently showed that the protection rate was more than adequate, and a portion of that sample came from South Africa. It even included some people who were HIV-positive. Why is that important?
The J&J vaccine is the SAME TECHNOLOGY used by AZ-Oxford. Same adenovirus carrier, same everything, as far as I can tell. While they come from different manufacturers, the end product should work in the same way.
So why does J&J's vaccine work well, but AZ-Oxford's does not? I don't see anyone asking that question. What are the possibilities?
1) The recent South African study is flawed. This is entirely possible since it has not been peer-reviewed. It could be a statistical problem, but most likely if there is a flaw, it would be in the methodology, such as the selection of the sample or the administration of the vaccine.
2) The J&J data are flawed. This is possible, but since J&J's data are similar to what Moderna and Pfizer are showing in their work, it is less likely.
3) Something about the AZ-Oxford vaccine is flawed. The AZ-Oxford vaccine has been plagued with problems throughout its development, even having to stop operations in the UK for a bit. It also had to stop its clinical trials because it couldn't get the dosages right. Maybe the AZ-Oxford vaccine is just poorly made.
4) The two studies are asking different questions. Maybe the South Africa study and the J&J study were measuring the vaccine effects differently. Without reading the studies themselves, we don't know.
In short, something stinks here. If I had to guess, I would guess that the recent AZ-Oxford study probably means that the AZ-Oxford vaccine never really worked, not that the variants are winning. Let's see how it all plays out.