13/09/2024
There are any number of motion picture directors who are more than happy to tell stories about their earlier, pre-industry lives and exploits, and often entertainingly so. And then there are some who go to lengths to hide their former, less savory lives from public exposure. Silent comedy director Scott Pembroke was one of the latter.
Scott Pembroke (1889-1951; born Percy Stanley Pembroke) is not what you’d call a household name, given that his run as a film director was confined primarily to the silent era, and almost exclusively to short comedies. His most prolific runs were for Hal Roach, Joe Rock, and the Stern Brothers, with the random film for others helped to fill in the gaps. There was the occasional feature as well, such as FOR LADIES ONLY (1927; co-directed with Henry Lehrman!) and THE DIVINE SINNER (1928). The earlier films frequently credit him as “Percy Pembroke” rather than the more common “Scott Pembroke.”
Pembroke’s start in the industry, however, was in front of the camera in films for Essanay at their Niles studio in later 1914, remaining with that company up until its close in 1916, with some side jobs for the Liberty Film Company in San Mateo in early 1915. Described as a “strong, manly type,” Pembroke found work with Kalem as well, where he starred in their THE HAZARDS OF HELEN serial. By 1917 he was with Universal, where he described his duties as “racing driver and actor,” and avoided being drafted by claiming exemptions of “dependents and crippled hand.” Pembroke would continue to appear in films into the mid-1920s for Universal, Metro, Balboa, and Bison, alternating from 1920 with his stints as director.
It's Pembroke’s earlier, darker years that seem to have been lost to history, or at least until I tracked it down for my book on the Stern Brothers, TIME IS MONEY! Born in Oakland, California to Samuel J. Pembroke and his wife, Marian Scott Pembroke, Percy soon fell in with a gang of his peers which came to be known as the “Jim Crow” gang. This didn’t end up well, when Pembroke and two of his friends were charged with the robbery and grizzly murder of an employee of a grocery store that took place in 1905, one of a series of crimes the youths were involved in. Pembroke turned on his two friends and gave evidence that resulted in their life sentences in prison. After two hung juries, sixteen-year-old Pembroke was acquitted during a third trial. The law didn’t give up on him, however, charging him in connection with a robbery that took place two years earlier. Found guilty and awaiting sentencing, the seemingly unfazed Pembroke made an unusually brazen and self-confident announcement, as reported in the San Francisco Call:
“Percy Pembroke today announced his intention to go on the stage as soon as he has obtained his freedom. He said that there was no necessity of a youth working hard who had had the advertising he had secured during the course of his five trials, and that he intended to utilize his notoriety to the best advantage.
‘There are plenty of courts this thing can go through,’ said Percy in speaking of his chances of appealing his case. ‘There is even the Supreme Court at Washington. If the bond is not too high—that is, in the neighborhood of $40,000 or $50,000—I can easily have my freedom while I can go on the road with a stock company which I have been planning to organize.’”
Self-confident little bu**er, huh?
Pembroke’s plans would be delayed for a while, however, when the now seventeen-year-old was sentenced in March 1907 to ten years in San Quentin.
As it turned out, Pembroke DID have some previous stage experience, having acted in actress Olga Nethersole’s production of SAPHO back in 1906. Four years later in 1910, Nethersole came to his aide and successfully applied to Governor Gillett for a pardon for Pembroke, and by 1914 he had received a full pardon. With his release, Pembroke resolved to stay on the straight and narrow, and by 1913 was working as a traveling sales rep for an Oakland-based outlet of the Regal Motor Car Company. There was some theatre work as well with roles at San Francisco’s Alcazar Theatre. And then he struck cinematic gold, entering the film industry and quietly sweeping his more sordid past under the carpet.
Pictured here: Photos of Pembroke are difficult to come by, but here are a few clipped from the trades. The caption of each provides the context.
If you’d like to learn more about Pembroke and his work in film, it’s covered in my book TIME IS MONEY! THE CENTURY, RAINBOW, AND STERN BROTHERS COMEDIES OF JULIUS AND ABE STERN (Thomas Reeder; BearManor Media, 1921).