06/06/2022
I passed on Old World a few weeks back cause I didn't like the art style. That watercolor high school textbook look holds appeal for a lot of strategy game enthusiasts and history buffs, but not me. I generally prefer the sci fi style 4x games with lots of pretty stars, cool spaceships, and weird alien races. It's a personal preference is all.
But those games aren't exactly being released in bulk, especially good ones. (As far as actual game enjoyment goes, I loved the remake of Master of Orion and that's pretty much it). In my desperation for a good 4x and after reading some critical acclaim, I gave Old World a second shot and I'm glad I did. For better or for worse, it IS the best 4x game available on the market today. Rather than focusing on inevitable conflicts and army buildup, each turn in the game presents a unique scenario for players to actually consider, giving them time and clarity to weigh all the potential options. It's not as drastic as Civilization...you won't find n**i Ghandi here...but it does allow you to play with things like national religion and shape your family lineage.
That's not to say there's no robust combat in the Old World. You will need an army, but there isn't the constant pressure to rush the most overpowered units in the game before the CPU can show up and wipe you off the map. Old World asks you to put together more of a minimal defense force for when conflict does occur, and this is easily handled by converting workers into militia or training up simple ground troops and adding court members as generals to lead them.
But what I like about the game most is that it lets me THINK, rather than instantly punishing me for making the wrong decision. I had a sovereign princess who went mad. She became queen and was still a capable ruler, but she encountered situations which could have turned disasterous if not for other aspects of her rule (her religious beliefs countered her paranoia). This is good stuff! A lesser game would have gone the roguelike route and made madness an all but certain game over. Not so here.
Old World takes some getting used to but I can honestly say its worth it. Its only the 3rd or 4th 4x game I can truly say I've enjoyed, but its easily the most surprisingly solid of that small bunch. 8/10
Old World is a revolutionary new historical strategy game where you lead your dynasty over generations of rule against rival kings and queens. Wage massive wars, manage your court, and build a dynasty — or watch your empire crumble to dust. What legacy will you leave behind?