11/30/2025
POST 2
🪙 We started a post series researching the reasons neighbors have stated they are for or against consolidation of our two governments.
🪙 The most common two reasons we saw or heard in favor of a government merger was reducing duplicative services and thereby reducing costs.
🪙Hardy states in a journal titled “The Pros and Cons of Consolidated Government” (see comment “Hardy, 2019” for source) that there are multiple studies showing mixed results for a reduction in costs. He continues in stating that “efficiency can only be realized in certain cases…what this probably means is that in order for efficiencies to occur, the ‘system’ must be actively and very well managed.” Later in the same article, Hardy asserts that while consolidation is an option for reducing or eliminating duplication of services he also proposed that the best method for this can be through other methods like interlocal agreements.
🪙The Citizens Research Council of Michigan (Michigan, 2020 in comments), highlighted an interesting pattern. They remark how consolidation in 1982 and 2000 were successful however the recent governmntal mergers have not been successful. They concluded that consolidation of services was more desirable over consolidation of governments for this reason.
🪙Other noteworthy information we discovered was a journal from Laura L. Payne, PhD (Payne, n.d). She used Jacksonville, Florida and Louisville, Kentucky as examples of mergers with no measurable increase in efficiency (maximizing the output of public services) but did improve financial status (budget).
🪙 However, a final study we will mention today (Hall, 2017), concluded that the economic success varies depending on the time examined and how economic progress is measured. They state that economic development is not guaranteed.
🪙These posts are very brief summaries of extensive writing and research. The information we mentioned here was observed across multiple articles, studies, and analyses which is why we included it here. We encourage all our neighbors to research more if they are led, and share what they find in the comments below.
✨We are better and more knowledgeable together. Keep the conversation going. Next post on consolidation: expanded services and less representation