31/12/2025
I read a short little commentary today, about Colton Underwood‘s take on Heated Rivalry that he published on his Substack. Got me wondering maybe I should be writing this on my Substack.
Regardless, the person chose to say nothing good about Underwood. From their perspective, Underwood is a horrible creep who doesn’t deserve any attention whatsoever.
If you don’t know who Colton Underwood is, Google him. He’s got quite a messy and full story. It makes perfect sense, however that he would have a take on HR given that he was an extremely closeted gay man in sports before he became a celebrity on the Bachelor. And after the Bachelor, or because of it? He acted extremely horribly towards his ex-girlfriend. 
Not every closeted sports figure piles their shame into their own loneliness. The closet creates enormous mess for many.
Totally separate from anything related to, HR, I have been thinking about some people I dated years and years ago. My early 20s were a really crazy messed up time for me. I didn’t seem to have an issue coming out as gay, or at least I didn’t think I did. But the reality is in my history, my past was lots of shame and self hatred and self blame.
And as I tried to become an adult and happy in life, I know that my s**t left a mess in very many relationships. The closet isn’t the only thing that causes people to be harmful to others.
I was in my late 20s, before I realized I needed to stop dating, and deal with fixing things in my life that didn’t really work. I’m far from the only person who’s had that experience  I know.
Where am I going with this? What my story, and Underwood story, and HR, and many stories having in common, is the impact of rigid, gender roles, and how various people try to conform to them. And how that conforming makes a mess for them and for others.
If there’s one moment in Heated Rivalry that isn’t getting enough attention, it is Scott Hunter’s speech. I think this gets overlooked because he talks about loneliness. The story of Shane and Ilya is a lot easier to handle because neither of them displayed loneliness. We love their story because it appears happy ever after. We’re all loving staying at the cottage. We want to stay in that moment of safety and vulnerability.
But one of the truly huge and important stories within HR, is the way masculinity and our drive to succeed at being real men  generates loneliness. How because of it, we end up on our own, when we truly need the support of others.
I truly believe that HR deserves all the attention it is getting, however, I’m surprised that more isn’t being said about Boots. Boots is very much a story that deals with this loneliness, during the process of a variety of individuals trying to find themselves. But for whatever reason, we were robbed of the happy ending. Perhaps some type of happy ending would’ve been in season two or season three of Boots if that show we’re going to continue. Maybe HR is so popular because not only was it a great story and told in a really wonderful way, but it was also a story that gave us what Boots didn’t? Maybe we aren’t really ready for stories that are about the loneliness, or the way the closet deprives so many of happiness.