03/07/2022
~In The Wake of Surrender: The Battle of Poplar Grove fought on this calendar day~
Just days after the Boers suffered what may have been their most crippling defeat of the Anglo-Boer War at the Battle of Paardeberg, the British closed in on a Boer force that included the South African Republic’s president … Paul Kruger. Some British leadership gravely misinterpreted what happened at the Battle of Poplar Grove.
But what happened on March 7, 1900 cannot be understood fully without painting a picture of what led to that battle. At the cost of around 1,500 casualties, almost all on February 18th while Kitchener wielded his men recklessly, the British dealt the Boers a crippling defeat. General Christiaan de Wet remembered the surrender like this: QUOTE “‘No pen can describe… the effect on the burghers. On every face there was dejection and despair to be seen. The demoralization—I cannot reiterate it enough—prevailed right through until the end of the war.”
Just like that ... 4,000 Boers prisoners sent into exile to an island over 1,000 miles away. Just like that … 10% of the existing Boer forces … removed from the field. Hundreds and hundreds more would return home. Many of the Boer progressives in both republics who had been reluctant to go to war in the first place now appeared prophetic. The whole of the Boer war effort looked like it could crumble completely. With Piet Cronje on his way with 4,000 others to St. Helena and Piet Joubert near death, Free State president Marthinus Steyn and Transvaal president Paul Kruger had little choice now to turn over the waging of war to younger leaders. Louis Botha took the title of commandant general of the Transvaal, … Christiaan De Wet in the Orange Free State. “Koos” De La Rey gained more authority, and the Transvaal State Attorney … Jan Smuts got the chance to prove himself as a leader of men in the field. Nasson writes QUOTE “De la Rey and De Wet had the biblical inspiration of a fundamentalist Christian warriorhood … zealous in belief ‘that by opposing British imperialism they were on a crusade for the Lord.’ Both veterans of the 1880s conflict with Britain, they had already demonstrated a flair for running swift movements in the field.” This war … would be over … if this new crop of leaders ...didn’t deliver. This new crop of Boer warrior leaders faced Boer morale that lay at an all time low. Kruger grew so desperate that he threatened to use police reserves to shoot Boer deserters if necessary. So what were the Boers to do now?
What the Boers were to do now depended on what Lord Roberts was going to do. And Lord Roberts wanted to take a knife to where he believed the Boer hearts were … the capitals of their republics. The Boer republics appeared as other European opponents had appeared to the British … with defined capitals at their center. Lord Roberts believed that bringing Bloemfontein and Pretoria to their knees would finish off the Boers. But Lord Roberts’s 40 years of experience came … in India. General Redvers Buller had fought alongside Boers some 20 years before and anticipated something very different from Lord Roberts. Buller believed the Boers would engage in guerrilla warfare like American colonists had over 100 years before. Buller thought the republican territory covered too much ground dotted by too many rural communities to fold … when their capitals fell. It was only a matter of time before one of these generals was proven right. As Roberts closed in on Bloemfontein, Christiaan De Wet decided to disrupt the British horde as much as possible. He managed to entrench between 5,000 & 6,000 commandos
at Poplar Grove. They dug in along a 10-mile front on both sides of the Modder River… about 30 miles east of Kimberley. Lord Roberts, with 30,000 men and over 100 guns, tried to immediately implement what he learned at Paardeberg. He sent French’s cavalry and other mounted infantry to make a 17-mile loop around the Boers east flank and then attack the Boers from the rear … from where Roberts believed the Boers would make an escape through. After French’s mounted men made this loop, 3 infantry divisions would attack using creeping barrage tactics … meaning the artillery would strike just enough ahead of the British infantry to keep Boer heads down as much as possible until British infantry had almost closed in on the Boers. As a side note, I had previously read that these creeping barrage tactics first emerged in WWI and … then I taught this to my sophomore world history students. Turns out these creeping barrage tactics emerged at least as early … as 1900 when Buller successfully used these against the Boers in the Battle of Pieters’ Heights aka Tugela Heights.
Anyway … Lord Roberts planned to use these creeping barrage tactics to avoid atrocious losses that his chief-of-staff Lord Kitchener recklessly reaped on February 18th at Paardeberg. Lord Roberts hoped to score another big bag of Boer captives through this encirclement. What Lord Roberts didn’t know was that President Paul Kruger showed up in his top hat to the Boer camp to inspire them to fight on. What Lord Roberts also did not know is something that De Wet could only have vaguely anticipated … but hoped against. At 3AM on March 7th, the British mounted men made their move. Boers all along their defensive line began to withdraw as the Boers realized that the British were trying to encircle them, as withdrawals at some positions made holding other positions impossible. De Wet was busy meeting with President Kruger while all these retreats unfolded. Nothing De Wet did could stop his left flank from running for Bloemfontein … so De Wet sent Kruger on the run as well to avoid capture. But Lord Roberts’s own men didn’t stick to the plan either. Major-General French decided his mens’ horses were too weary to make the full loop behind Boer lines, so French broke off their loop early and sent his force careening towards where the main body of the Boers … was. French also pulled Brigadier-General Robert Broadwood’s cavalry from their advanced positions behind Boer lines for this attack at the center. This … initiative by French left a whole wide enough for fleeing Boers to run through … toward Bloemfontein. Boer snipers also slowed French’s weary cavalry enough to prevent the capture of any Boers. French also slowed his cavalry himself by having them advance at a walk, even dismounted … so French had many of his cavalrymen fight on foot making it much easier for De Wet’s ad hoc rearguard snipers to slow their advance. The Boer force didn’t wait to be surrounded and captured. They lived to fight another day.
Lord Roberts was furious. Blame went back and forth between him and his officers. Roberts said this about Major-General French: QUOTE “We should have had a good chance of making the two Presidents prisoner if French had carried out my orders of making straight for Modder River, instead of wasting valuable time going after small parties of the enemy.” Roberts also accused French of running his horses into the ground. French was furious. He blamed the breakdown of his horses on Roberts’s disruptive changes to the transport system. French’s Chief of Staff, one Douglas Haig, said QUOTE “I have never seen horses so beat as ours that day. … They have been having only 8 pounds of oats a day and practically starving since … February 11th.” Haig blamed this on Roberts diverting some of their allotted feed to other colonial cavalry corps that Roberts raised. Roberts also blamed Lieutenant-General Kelly-Kenney for moving his infantry too slowly against the Boers. But Kelly-Kenney in turn blamed the dehydration and near starvation brought by De Wet’s earlier capture of 200 British supply wagons on … Roberts’s mismanagement. Since then, Kelly-Kenney’s men only had one water cart for each battalion to share. The British “won” the battle of Poplar Grove, but the Boers only suffered 50 … or only 2 casualties … depending which historian you ask. Regardless, Pretorius writes that QUOTE “The seeds of the future guerrilla warfare had been sown.” Pakenham wrote this about the Battle of Poplar Grove’s aftermath: QUOTE “Whoever was to blame, the effects of the Battle of Poplar Grove were disastrous and long-lasting for the British. Not only did Roberts fail to catch Kruger and the rest. He also made the crucial deduction from the panic-stricken way the Boers had fled … that the Boers’ morale was broken, and the war nearly over.”
To learn more about the events surrounding Poplar Grove, check out episode 1.34 of the Forgotten Wars Podcast almost anywhere podcasts are provided. To get a fuller picture of the Anglo-Boer War, you can start at episode 1.22; to get a fuller picture of all the preceding conflicts, start at episode 1.3.
Episode 1.34 on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-1-34-the-road-to-bloemfontein-in-this/id1535351938?i=1000522496549m
Episode 1.34 on Google Podcasts: https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zaW1wbGVjYXN0LmNvbS9KM09KV0xIeQ/episode/MWY5MmUzOGYtZDc0My00MmQzLWIxZmUtMjk0NzY2YTVhYmNi?sa=X&ved=0CAUQkfYCahcKEwjI2p7un7T2AhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQCg&hl=en-MX