
05/29/2025
🎬🎬 The Unbelievable Truth (1989), directed by Hal Hartley, is a quirky, minimalist indie gem that launched both Hartley’s career and that of actress Adrienne Shelly. Set in a Long Island suburb, the film follows the quietly brooding Josh (Robert Burke), a mysterious mechanic with a criminal past, as he returns to his hometown and crosses paths with Audry (Adrienne Shelly), a restless high school girl with existential leanings.
The film plays like a deadpan romantic comedy filtered through existential philosophy. Audry is determined to escape her suburban fate—rejecting college and modeling in favor of pursuing a deeper, if elusive, truth. Josh, haunted by what may or may not be a murder he committed, tries to lead a quiet life, but becomes an object of fascination and moral panic.
Hartley’s signature style—deadpan dialogue, abrupt emotional shifts, ironic detachment—is already fully formed here. Characters speak in stilted, philosophical lines that somehow become poignant, even funny, in their awkwardness. The film’s lo-fi aesthetic and offbeat rhythm feel both homemade and carefully constructed.
At its core, The Unbelievable Truth is about how people invent narratives—about others, about themselves—to make sense of a chaotic world. Everyone in the film seems to be misreading everyone else, projecting fears or desires instead of seeking understanding.
Adrienne Shelly brings a vibrant, vulnerable intensity to Audry, balancing idealism and cynicism in a way that feels authentic. Burke’s Josh is the perfect counterpoint: stoic, inward, and burdened by guilt.
Though small in scale, the film is rich in emotional undercurrents. It’s a story about second chances, misplaced judgment, and the quiet absurdity of everyday life. The Unbelievable Truth is a wry, poetic debut that still holds up as a hallmark of 1980s American indie cinema.