18/05/2025
The disappearance of Kristin Smart (part 2)
Written By: Enrique Melendez
Social Media Contributing Writer
photo of Kristin’s family provided by The New York Times
After years of searching, and the case becoming cold, a new sheriff, a podcast, and a desperate family go beyond their limitations in locating new evidence, but is it enough to get the justice they are seeking?
An unwavering case
A new path towards discovery sparks hope in 2010 when San Luis Obispo’s newly elected sheriff, Ian Parkinson, stated that he would review the case. Six years later, in September 2016, they conducted a massive search of the area around Cal Poly. After four days, no new evidence was uncovered.
Kristin’s family, the Murphys, were still in the fight, but it wasn’t until September 2019 when Chris Lambert launched his podcast “Your Own Backyard” and the case reignited.
The podcast tells the story of Kristin Smart and the mystery of her disappearance. The podcast received attention, as other witnesses came forward about Paul’s reputation in school. Many witnesses were women who had contact with Paul, naming him a “molester,” a former classmate stated. They highlight his behavior more, as he was known as someone who would grope women.
The podcast came to the attention of the newly appointed sheriff, Ian Parkinson, who collaborated with Chris to discover new information that the first investigation missed. According to ABC, after Paul’s family moved out of their home, they put it up for rent. A few months later, the current tenants found a piece of jewelry by the driveway. They assumed it was an earring. Those tenants later told investigators that when they found it, there was a little red smudge mark like a fingerprint on the back of it.
To the surprise of the Smart family, they discovered that the earring was a piece of Kristin’s necklace, and to the investigator’s surprise, the billboard that the family released in 1997 had a picture of Kristin wearing that necklace.
As Chris’s podcast gathered more witnesses, he was later contacted by Mary Lassiter, who was the tenant who found the earring. Mary stated that a few months after she had moved in, she heard a beeping sound, so one night, she went outside looking for the sound in the flowerpots in the yard. She poked around awhile until the beeping stopped. Mary also stated that the beeping would occur at 4:20 AM.
This shocked the Smart family when they told investigators that Kristin was a lifeguard and that she would have her alarm set so she be able to arrive at work by 5 AM.
Years went by, and the case allowed law enforcement to search the home several times, but no new evidence came to light. Kristin’s sister, Lindsey, told CBS that her parents never gave up, “I think they’re, like, carrying boulders on their backs.”
In February 2021, a search warrant was approved to search the properties owned by Paul’s father, Ruben Flores. Authorities used cadaver dogs as well as ground penetrating radar and recovered items of interest that were not released to the public.
With enough evidence gathered following the recent revival, the case investigators acted immediately to apprehend Paul Flores.
Conclusion
ABC reported that on April 13, 2021, Paul Flores and his father, Ruben, were arrested at their Los Angeles home. Paul was charged with the murder of Kristin Smart, and his father was charged with helping him.
On April 14, Kristin’s parents released a statement after the arrest, stating,” It is impossible to put into words what this day means for our family,” praying this was the first step in finding their daughter. The family went through a long preliminary hearing, and on July 18, 2022, the trial of Paul and his father began.
During the trial, San Luis Obispo County District Attorney Dan Dow stated that he found that the impact of Kristin’s disappearance had a profound effect on the Smart family and the community spanning over 20 years.
The trial revealed evidence from the searches of Ruben’s properties, where they recovered DNA on plywood under the house that investigators disclosed to be human blood. This discovery was invaluable. They also discovered red fibers, which Mustang news reported, could have belonged to a pair of Kristin’s shoes she was wearing on the night she went missing.
A testimony from another witness of the party, Kendra Koed, testified that Paul tried to kiss Kristin several times until Kristin pushed him away. Prosecution used this to conclude that Paul may have sexually assaulted Kristin. Paul’s defense attorney, Robert Sanger, countered when accusations of sexual assault were made, stating, “even if you believe that you still can’t use it in this case because there’s no proof beyond a reasonable doubt that Paul r***d or attempted to r**e her.”
The trial proceeded for four months. Evidence, DNA, and witnesses were presented, and on October 18, 2022, after over 20 years, a verdict was found. Kristin’s family bundled together, shedding tears. Paul Flores was found guilty of the murder of Kristin Smart and sentenced to 25 years to life in prison. The case had been won in part. However, due to insufficient evidence, Paul’s father, Ruben, was acquitted of his charges.
After the verdict, San Luis Obispo County Sheriff Ian Parkinson stated he was “extremely pleased with the jury’s decision.”
The case of Kristin Smart did receive a victory from this verdict, but this does not take away the pain that the Smart family continues to bear. Due to the lack of new evidence in the following years, Kristin’s body has yet to be recovered.
In 2024, the smart family filed a civil lawsuit against Cal Poly for negligence and wrongful death of their loved one. The status of the lawsuit has yet to receive a definitive ruling as of 2025.