12/12/2025
I pressed play on the Audible version of Katherine May’s Enchantment during a Tuesday commute because I loved Wintering and trusted her way of seeing the world. A few chapters in, I noticed something unsettling: I couldn’t remember the last time I’d truly paid attention to anything. I was moving through my days; competent, efficient, always in motion, but life had quietly turned into a checklist.
May describes a kind of modern inattentiveness: how we live through layered screens, how even reading or taking a walk becomes another moment where the mind slips away. Listening to her, I realized I’d been treating my attention like a resource to manage instead of the lens I actually live through.
What I appreciated is that she doesn’t shame this. She names it as her own struggle. And in doing so, she reminds you that this constant distraction isn’t inevitable—it’s learned. Which means it can be unlearned.
Here are some revealing and empowering insights from this beautiful book:
1. The Productivity Trap We Don't Name
There's a moment where May describes feeling guilty for taking a walk without a clear purpose—not for exercise, not for errands, just to walk. I nearly laughed out loud in the car. Every activity in my life had to justify itself: better health, useful knowledge, career advancement. Doing something for its own sake felt almost transgressive.
May argues that we've let productivity colonize not just our work but our entire existence. We've forgotten that humans need spaciousness, need time that's not optimized for output. Enchantment can't survive in the margins. It needs room to breathe. This isn't laziness—it's how we stay connected to being alive.
2. Befriending the Dark Seasons
May refuses to pathologize difficulty. She writes about how our culture demands constant positivity, constant growth, constant light. But life includes winters—periods when nothing blooms, when we feel dormant. These aren't aberrations to fix but necessary rhythms.
Reading this made me recognize how exhausting it's been trying to maintain the same energy year-round, the same productivity, the same enthusiasm. May writes about watching the natural world move through seasons without apology and asks why we think we're exempt. There's something profoundly relieving about being given permission to have seasons.
3. Making Without Monetizing
May champions doing things badly, slowly, without any goal beyond the doing itself. Creating things no one will see, learning skills that won't appear on your resume. In a world where every hobby is supposed to become a side hustle, this feels quietly radical.
She describes her own forays into various crafts—not for an audience, not for social media, just done. It made me realize how long it had been since I'd done anything that didn't have an ulterior motive. Everything had become instrumental. May suggests this instrumentalization is part of what's draining enchantment from life.
4. Practicing Enchantment Deliberately
What surprised me most was May's insistence that enchantment isn't just something that happens to you—it's something you practice. A skill that atrophies without use. She writes about relearning how to notice: taking the long way home, learning bird names, paying attention to how light changes, creating small rituals that anchor you in the present.
This isn't Instagram-aesthetic self-care. It's building a different relationship with daily life, one that leaves space for wonder. She's honest that it feels awkward at first. You're standing there looking at a tree, feeling self-conscious. But gradually, with practice, the world starts speaking again in a language you'd forgotten.
I'm three months past finishing the audiobook, and I keep thinking about something May says: that we're not broken, the capacity for wonder hasn't disappeared, we've just built lives that make it nearly impossible to access. This reframing shifted something. I'd been blaming myself for feeling disconnected. May helped me see it as structural, a consequence of how we've organized modern life.
I haven't reclaimed enchantment completely. I still spend too much time on my phone, still feel the compulsive pull of productivity. But now I recognize what's missing. I notice when I'm on autopilot. And sometimes—not always—I remember to stop. To actually look. To let moments exist for their own sake.
May offers us a sustainable way of paying attention, reminds us to slow down, and that we're allowed to want more than efficiency from our lives. May's Enchantment might just help you see what you've been missing—and that you're allowed to want it back.
BOOK: https://amzn.to/4pqpTsg
Enjoy the audiobook with a membership trial using the same link.