22/11/2022
With national elections over, the locals are lining up in anticipation of next year’s municipal elections in Tzfat. The quality of our day-to-day lives depends largely on how local government operates.
So how do you think we’re doing?
We have a right to expect a lot better. Most of us are not dazzled by kikarot or signs professing love for our great city. The cultural divide between local Israelis and Anglo olim are most evident surrounding politics.
Americans are used to transparency. City council and other legislative bodies are required to announce all public meetings and encourage citizens to participate. Major issues, like budgets, building and social service issues receive regular interaction with residents. Public information officers are readily available to disseminate information, and officials are well known and accessible to citizens. Building permits must be posted and supervised, and there are community representatives eager to get public input. Political influence and gifts are carefully monitored, and nepotism closely scrutinized. Conflicts of interest are examined and city staff prioritizes citizen inquiries.
Not so here.
There is no public posting of moatza (city council) meetings, and the public is discouraged from attending- as evidenced by the tiny room where they are held. While the current mayor is not one to miss a photo opp, he does not conduct open meetings, and appointments are difficult to get. It has been over two years since the public information officer left, and the only source of news is the mayor’s social media posts.
While we are one of the poorest cities in the country, it took over two years for a replacement to be named to the social service department- leaving the position open during the height of Covid. Tourism is our # 1 industry, yet we have no tourist officer or information center. Parking and traffic is a nightmare, and our distressed Midrachov with dirty, inaccessible facilities and the filthy street has made the lack of economic development even more apparent. The replacement of a dozen badly needed parking spaces next to city hall with another kikar that has limited seating and no garbage cans is yet another indication of what matters to the powers that be.
The “Olim move to Tzfat” talking points provide no back up. The city has a deputy mayor in charge of immigration with a staff dedicated to bringing the Russian community enormous resources including community centers, tutoring programs, chess clubs, social events and a library. Anglo olim receive none of these benefits or considerations. There have been three city liaisons to the Anglo community in the last four years who worked tirelessly with just lip service in return. The position has been vacant for many months, and hopeful olim who come with the dream of buying property here are thwarted when trying to get proper permits, while friends of the city build illegally as the city turns a blind eye.
Ziffer Garden remains closed and a disabled woman has been restricted access to her home for years because the city won’t enforce a judgement.
Our city is filthy. Yes, residents and tourists have a lot to do with it, but the city needs to take a leadership role. More bins and garbage cans throughout the city, with regular and thorough pickups. Signage and fines for dumping and littering. Clean up all public restrooms and power wash Jerusalem Street more than just at festival time.
The city cannot promote itself as a center of art and music if they do not promote, support and encourage music and art. Holy sites must be maintained. The divide between religious factions must be tightened.
Nepotism and cronyism need to stop. Corruption and collusion need to be challenged. The mayor’s son should not be drawing a salary from the city basketball team and his lovely but inexperienced wife is not a qualified Knesset candidate. Showy doesn’t mean substantive, and don’t say you care when we know you care more about power than you care about doing the right thing for our holy city.
The candidates now lining up are familiar faces with the same message.. We are a year away from elections and already social media posts are filled with anger, attacks and personal vendettas.
Our beloved city deserves to be led by men and women with vision, commitment and a desire to maximize our great potential. We deserve to choose from the best of the best, not from the best of the worst.
Will moral, creative and independent, owe-nothing-to-anybody citizens like be motivated to come forward? Will other potential leaders be inspired to step up, challenge the status quo and help us achieve our great potential?
It’s time for new leadership.
By
Susan Cohen
With national elections over, the locals are lining up in anticipation of next year’s municipal elections in Tzfat.
The quality of our day-to-day living depends largely on how local government operates. So how do you think we’re doing?
We have a right to expect a lot better. Most of us are not dazzled by kikarot or signs professing love for our great city.
The cultural differences between the local Israelis and Anglo olim are most evident surrounding politics. Americans are used to transparency. City council and other legislative bodies are required to announce all public meetings and encourage citizens to participate. Major issues, like budgets, building and social services receive regular interaction with residents. Public information officers are readily available to disseminate information, and officials are well known and accessible to citizens. Building permits must be posted and supervised, and there are community representatives eager to get public input. Political influence and gifts are carefully monitored, and nepotism closely scrutinized. Conflicts of interest are examined and city staff prioritizes citizen inquiries.
Not so here.
There is no public posting of moatza (city council) meetings, and the public is discouraged from attending- as evidenced by the tiny room where they are held. While the current mayor is not one to miss a photo opp, he does not conduct open meetings, and appointments are difficult to get. It has been over two years since the public information officer left, and the only source of news is the mayor’s social media posts. While we are one of the poorest cities in the country, it took over two years for a replacement to be named to the social service department- leaving the position open during the height of Covid. Tourism is our # 1 industry, yet we have no tourist officer or information center.
Parking and traffic is a nightmare, and our distressed Midrachov with dirty, inaccessible facilities and the filthy street has made the lack of economic development even more apparent. The replacement of a dozen badly needed parking spaces next to city hall with another kikar that has limited seating and no garbage cans is yet another indication of what matters to the powers that be.
The “Olim move to Tzfat” talking points provide no back up. The city has a deputy mayor in charge of immigration with a staff dedicated to bringing the Russian community enormous resources including community centers, tutoring programs, chess clubs, social events and a library. Anglo olim receive none of these benefits or considerations. There have been three city liaisons to the Anglo community in the last four years who worked tirelessly with just lip service in return. The position has been vacant for many months, and hopeful olim who come with the dream of buying property here are thwarted when trying to get proper permits, while friends of the city build illegally as the city turns a blind eye. Ziffer Garden remains closed and a disabled woman has been restricted access to her home for years because the city won’t enforce a judgement. Kids are roaming the streets and runaways are living in abandoned buildings because there are almost no extracurricular, enrichment or mental health resources available.
Our city is filthy. Yes, the residents have a lot to do with it, but the city needs to take a leadership role. More bins and garbage cans throughout the city, with regular and thorough pickups. Signage and fines for dumping and littering. Clean up all public restrooms and power wash Jerusalem Street more than just at festival time.
The city cannot promote itself as a center of art and music if they do not promote, support and encourage music and art. Holy sites must be maintained. The divide between religious factions must be tightened.
Nepotism and cronyism need to stop. Corruption and collusion need to be challenged. The mayor’s son should not be drawing a salary from the city basketball team and his lovely but inexperienced wife is not a qualified Knesset candidate. Showy doesn’t mean substantive, and don’t say you care when we know you care more about power than you care about doing the right thing for our holy city.
The candidates now lining up are familiar faces- no women. We are a year away from elections and already social media posts are filled with anger, attacks and personal vendettas.
Our beloved city deserves to be led by men and women with vision, commitment and a desire to maximize our great potential. We deserve to choose from the best of the best, not from the best of the worst.
Will moral, creative and independent, owe-nothing-to-anybody citizens like Aron Kita or Yona Cohen be motivated to come forward? Will other potential leaders be inspired to step up, challenge the status quo and help us achieve our great potential?
It’s time for new leadership.,,,