28/09/2020
What are your thoughts on this troops?
This has been causing a huge amount of interest since it was posted on the Interweb recently.
Whilst it would not have been inconceivable for Pink Floyd to have provided backing for this track as a favour to Norman Smith, the more I look into this, the more unlikely it seems.
Researching the files at Abbey Road for The Complete Pink Floyd there were quite a few out-takes that have since been accounted for or have been officially released. The one true anomaly is this track. I and others before and after me have speculated as to its authenticity but without further documentation, it has reached a dead-end.
The studio engineers at Abbey Road were extremely methodical at logging studio time and this is literally the only thing that lends credence to this item. But, and this is big but, the studio was booked between 7pm and 2am on 23 October 1967. All Pink Floyd did that day was to record some overdubs onto an already complete take of 'Set The Controls ...'. This would hardly have taken 7 hours (although admittedly they were no strangers to wasting studio time!).
Assuming therefore Pink Floyd finished their session early as is likely, Norman Smith would have then had time to bring in William Butler (and friends) to record a one-off solo demo. And, as it was all done in one take, it would have been very easy to slip this under the radar. William Butler's band Gullivers People recorded a handful of Norman Smith produced singles for Parlophone, so he was no stranger to Abbey Road. Norman Smith was also a multi-instrumentalist himself so a bit of pedestrian drumming along with William Butler's guitar work was all that was required, although there are obviously other instruments and presumably musicians on this track.
I have also re-read David Parker's excellent book Random Precision. He also wrote to Nick Mason (in 2001) and he couldn't recall anything of this. I feel this is something that would stick in your mind despite how hectic Pink Floyd’s schedule was at that time.
I think if Pink Floyd had demonstrated they had done this sort of session work before in that period it may be credible, but as it stands and with Mason's testimony, I doubt it very much.
THIS ACETATE WILL BE SOLD AT - WESSEX AUCTION ROOMS on the 16th of October 2020. PINK FLOYD & William “Billy” Butler (William “Henry” Butler) - EARLY MORNING...