25/09/2026
Manufacturing Consent.
A new survey says 43% of the public support compulsory military service for young people.
That headline sounds rather different once you ask who is expected to do the serving.
Among 18 to 24-year-olds, the very people who could find themselves ordered into uniform, support is just 15%. Among the over-65s, safely beyond the reach of conscription, it rises to 66%.
So the strongest support for compulsory military service comes from those least likely ever to be compelled to serve.
Funny how easily “national duty” rolls off the tongue when it is somebody else’s youth, somebody else’s freedom and, if the politicians get their war, somebody else’s blood.
Perhaps the more revealing headline is this:
85% of 18 to 24-year-olds do not support compulsory military service.
Consent looks rather different when you ask the people expected to pay the price.
And there is another question almost nobody bothers to ask: who is supposed to train thousands of unwilling young people who do not want to be there?
Britain has long prided itself on a professional volunteer force. That matters. A volunteer joins knowing what they have signed up for and is trained inside a military culture built around commitment, discipline and cohesion. A conscript army is a very different proposition.
You do not create an effective fighting force simply by dragging reluctant young people through the barrack gates. You need instructors, accommodation, equipment, time, money and an entire training system capable of turning unwilling civilians into competent soldiers. What sort of training do you get when the intake does not want the job and the existing forces are expected to absorb them?
Perhaps the more revealing headline is this:
85% of 18 to 24-year-olds do not support compulsory military service.
Before Westminster starts dreaming of conscription, it might first explain who will train them, what sort of army it expects to create, and why the generation being volunteered for it wants so little to do with the idea.
It is easy to demand national service when somebody else is being served up.